[scarface_74]

You pay $25 a seat to either Google (GSuite) or Microsoft. There is nothing to manage but signing into the account.

As far as computer purchasing, my latest employer had my computer shipped directly from Apple. Once I got it, I installed the mandated MDM software.

[zie]

You clearly have never dealt with their support system(s).

You still need a geek or geek adjacent person. Their stuff breaks all the time in weird and wonderful ways and someone local has to figure that out and send trouble tickets in to the vendor(s).

With Google, you pretty much can't get support, even if you are a paying customer, so you absolutely have to have your own human, if only to tell you: You can't use Google that way...

With MS you can get support, but you pay extra for it, and it's hit and miss as to how useful it is.

With Apple, you get support. It's generally pretty good, but can occasionally fail.

[scarface_74]

What do you think can “break” with logging in to your Google account and using GSuite? It’s basically the same thing as the consumer version.

It’s the same with O365.

[halfcat]

Email notifications from your CRM stop getting delivered to your employee’s inboxes (which means your business is losing revenue). CRM vendor says ”problem isn’t on our end”. Hopefully someone at your company understands DNS and MX records and SPF records and SMTP headers in log files so you can go back to your CRM vendor and keep barking up the chain until you get someone who understands how Mailgun works so you can explain to them how to fix their problem.

When evaluating options, I’ve learned to ask myself the question, ”how do I fix this if it breaks?” If my answer is, ”it won’t ever break”, I’ve learned it’s always a red flag that says I don’t understand enough about that solution to support it, because everything can (and will) break.

[scarface_74]

This is a mail gun issue then isn’t it? Hosted email by Microsoft was one of the early SaaS products and the entire reason the original AJAX was created by Microsoft for IE

[halfcat]

Yes, but it also wasn’t going to get fixed without in-house tech expertise.

Or flip it around. Your marketing is using Mailgun, and they just ran an expensive marketing campaign, but none of the emails are going out.

Or the marketing person says Mailgun sucks so they just send mass marketing emails from their work email and now your domain is on a blacklist.

An employee gets phished and their email sends out spam to all your vendors. Your main supplier blocks your domain until their IT can talk to your IT to confirm your IT has fixed the issue. ”we reset their password” isn’t going to cut it.

Your cybersecurity insurance renewal requires 2FA and geoblocking login attempts. Your office manager thinks they maybe figured it out, but now no one in your organization can login.

At the very least you need someone on retainer you can call. The cheapest option, if you can find one, is finding an IT consulting company that works on a time & materials basis. That way you aren’t paying continually but you’re not dead in the water when something breaks.

[zie]

Google closing your account for some random reason. Their API's being maliciously compliant. Their systems being down. Browser/client compatibility issues. Network/connectivity issues, etc.

Users being stupid, using and holding it wrong, etc.

Just because you haven't had any bad experiences with Google, MS, Apple, etc doesn't mean it's a rosy world where everything works all the time.

[scarface_74]

Have you seen any reports of Google randomly closing business accounts? What do you think the reliability of Google’s servers compared to an in house managed server? Have you ever known GSuite not be available with Chrome?

As far as network/connectivity, how is that a Google problem if your office can’t connect to the internet?

[zie]

Yes, Google closes business accounts too. Just search on HN, there are plenty of instances of this happening that have made it to HN. More if you go dig around on the web.

In my experience Cloud provider reliability is about the same as self-hosting. They claim to have super reliable uptime, and it's hard to see history, but they regularly have small outages in various regions, areas, etc.

In real world anecdata I've had our Google stuff stop working more often than some of my stuff, though my stuff is very stable and never changes, except relevant security updates, so it's not entirely a fair comparison. Also our stuff is running on over-sized hardware and can handle 2 node outages without issue. Since the hardware this stuff uses is on a 4hr support contract, it's very, very rare that even one node goes down for more than a day. Of course we pay a lot for that stability, on purpose.

I agree IF you use Chrome, then Google's browser compatibility issues are near zero. Not everyone uses Chrome.

It's not a Google problem, but it is still a USER problem someone has to manage and handle.

Clearly you have never done much if any end-user support.

[ajb]

Stuff does occasionally break. In my last place Google managed to wipe the HR drive. (Yes, I checked the audit logs to see if it was user error - nope). Of course, it should have been backed up, but HR were the only people with access so it wasn't.

It was fortunate that we were paying for the level where there was a separate way for discovery lawyers to suck out all your files, as that was the only way I found to get them back.

The other issue with gsuite is the file ownership model means that by default files are owned by an individual and can end up being lost after they leave. Transferring ownership is some kind of weird batch job that can fail and need to be retried.

[lostlogin]

> It’s the same with O365.

If you have a company on O365 and don’t ever need IT support, you either have a very very small company or are living the dream surrounded by unicorns.

Something is broken at least every day or two and I’m on a full MS stack. Hopefully we manage to dump Teams in the near future and this’ll hopefully get significantly better. Teams is the bulk of the issues.

[jcz_nz]

OMG. It's an absolute pile of crap on fire. Not just teams - Exchange/Outlook is as bad.

Last year we had Mac users start to report "when I attach a file, it looks like it's sent, but then recipient never sees it, and sent-emails doesn't show it either!" It got worse and worse.

This is kind of a problem in a business that sends and reviews a lot of documents. I spent two months on countless calls with MS, repeatedly capturing videos they requested, etc.

Finally, I happened to come across an advisory that hey, Outlook for Mac is broken, and will "eat" attachments. Dated a week before we started to see the problem. Firstly, it took them MONTHS to get it resolved as it required significant updates to Exchange. Secondly, in all the interactions I had to have with their support team: they had NO IDEA. Worse than useless.

[scarface_74]

And no one can say what exactly.

What has broken about using any of o365?

[dijit]

These are some I had over the last few months actually;

"I can't save outside of onedrive"

"My mails aren't getting delivered"

"My office suite has deactivated itself and won't reactivate"

"We need a shared mailbox for x,y,z"

"The new joiner can't access my onedrive/shared drive" (No groups/auto-groups - they require some more advanced administration or discipline).

"I received an email from someone impersonating the CEO asking for an invoice to be paid immediately"

"My Excel sheet is somehow not syncing to onedrive and now there's conflicts"

FD: We don't use Teams, and we migrated from o365 to GSuite, but there are some people who remain on o365 for Office reasons.

[lostlogin]

This list is a good summary. We have a lot of issues with logging in and two factor. Initial login and setup is particularly fraught.

And Teams. Everything. My personal favourite is document format screw ups (‘corruption’ might be the right word) depending on which Word was used (app, browser, Teams Word). It’s such a shit product. Document footer problems and page numbering issues are a complete waste of my time.

Spending the first 10 minutes of every call trying to get sound working for everyone. Hey Teams, don’t switch what mic you are using.

[jazzyjackson]

Teams won’t display any usernames for an external company that added to me their chat, everyone is Unknown. Maybe misconfig, something to do with cross domain permissions, but it feels buggy and broke.

Excel has some funk around keeping shared files in sync. We set up one spreadsheet where I have read only access so I don’t accidentally delete anything. Turns out when I do make a change, excel creates a locally cached version and stops syncing changes. That took a couple hours of screwing around to figure out, and the solution was to duplicate the spreadsheet with a new name and delete the old one.

[bluecheese452]

For teams there was a month where every single call it would lag out for 5+ seconds every minute or more. Just completely unusable.

[frizlab]

There are many ways in which a cloud suite can fail. I was the guy zie is talking about for many years though it was not my main job.

[aembleton]

Can you name any of these ways in which a cloud suite can fail?

[pas]

payment doesn't go through, for example.

because the CEO/founder's card has a limit.

we had this ~10 years ago where I was also the aforementioned IT guy for on-offboarding, doing whatever needs to be done for marketing, to set one more TXT record, to add one more email alias, to host one more PDF file, and so on.

because this is typical when you are at the size that you have a lot of SaaS subscriptions and you need to manage them, but still way too small to have institutional muscle memory (with semi-dedicated long-hauler folks, proper enterprise accounts with good separation of concerns/controls).

[scarface_74]

That’s not a technical problem or one unique to SaaS. Someone has to be responsible for onboarding and off boarding and making sure suppliers and vendors are paid.

A lot of the HR stuff ironically can also be handled by a PEO for small businesses.

https://www.rippling.com/aso

While your employer as far as hiring, firing, internal management is your actual company. As far as health benefits and payroll taxes you are “co employed” by the PEO

[baobun]

Misconfiguration and skill issues (aka poor docs).

IME not a big difference vs 99% of the failures of business IT systems in general...

[TheNewsIsHere]

Respectfully, as someone who manages Microsoft/Office 365, it’s absolutely not the same as the consumer editions. Those services run on different infrastructure and for the most part are different products/services. That isn’t just obvious from APIs and UXs; Microsoft also points it out all over documentation and processes.

Microsoft’s assumption is that businesses are using 365, and so both the number of features and the various paths to trouble tend reflect that.

To the random business owner, dropping them into anything other than Microsoft Admin Center is akin to dropping a tier one helpdesk agent into the AWS Management Console with no guidance. The trick is once you’re beyond a handful of employees you typically need to work beyond the MS Admin Center. If you want to do anything remotely sophisticated with identities, deploy SSO, etc, you need to be working from the Azure or (duplicative) Entra portals. If you want to do something like route helpdesk email, you need to be in the Exchange Admin Center. Tweaking spam filters is in yet another portal (currently Security Center, although that has changed a few times). And so on. Not to mention the more esoteric features that are only available behind Graph API calls.

I used to administer Google Workspace environments too, and while that control panel is MUCH more friendly, it’s still exceedingly easy for a non-technical person following a random walkthrough online to foul up their environment. I’ve watched that happened first hand many times.