Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by PavlovsCat 2784 days ago
> you're making a domain error when you conflate the forces of physical chemistry during first mitosis with higher level cognitive phenomenon of self-perception and identity. i hope you recognize that.

No, I'm using a figure of speech, and you're responding to nothing, certainly not the strongest possible interpretation.

> and you're entirely wrong about society being a fiction and therefore it not being real enough to matter.

You simply don't understand a word of what I say, as I say it.

The very first words of my first comment in this thread were

> Yes, we look for confirmation, just like we give it

Which makes it clear I don't "denounce others" or say "the outside is an illusion", or any of those plump distortions of my words, laced with big words, you offer. Apart from "I agree with your politics" which is like saying "I think it's fine you're beating your dog". I'm not beating my dog, I wasn't proposing politics, I disagreed with something. Initially by asking a question, to let the other person maybe elaborate on something I got wrong, etc. Well so much for that, I guess that boat sailed. Yet you are not OP and cannot answer my questions to them. As it turns out, you can't even give your own answers, because you distort what I say or ask before you even interact with it.

Simply because I disagree with one extreme, you put words about another extreme into my mouth. As far as I'm concerned, you haven't actually addressed any of what I said, and I'm done wasting my time.

1 comments

you're complaining about how i'm not understanding your beliefs in exactly the way that you want to be interpreted, so the only recourse you have is to turn away and act as if my interpretations ultimately don't matter, which is exactly in line with your stated belief that meaning is internal. i won't see you the way you see yourself, so now i'm wasting your time and making extreme statements, and there's nothing you can do about it except close yourself off.
Well, I agree with PavlovsCat and disagree with you. So in our little mini society of at least 3 people in this thread, a society which is not fiction (as you said), there is nothing you can do about it, except to take the feedback we give you, I guess.
that's not true. since i believe that meaning is external, the correct thing for me to do is either continue to try to convince you, or kill you both if you don't compromise a meaningful way forward.