Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by marcusbooster 6110 days ago
"Far from heralding in a "2001: Space Odyssey" dystopia, Baron believes that social networking sites, blogs and the Internet are actually making us better writers and improving our ability to reach out to our fellow man."

That's an odd movie reference. Maybe the writer is referring to the scene where the astronaut is watching a video from his family and reacts very distant and aloof. I thought that was more of a comment on the vast physical distance and isolation involved in space travel, not necessarily by an evolution in attitude caused by technology - his family seems like they are having a good enough time at least.

So it doesn't matter how efficient our social networking sites get or how lovely Facebook chat is, there will still be an 18-minute lag getting the signal on a ship heading to Jupiter.

Maybe I missed the point, but I really like that flick :)

2 comments

Also, HAL 9000 was "born" in Urbana, Illinois. I doubt that sheds any light on why the author included the reference, but it definitely overlaps. (EDIT: Dennis Baron, the author of the book discussed in the article, teaches at Urbana-Champaign).

I think you might be onto something with the way 2001 depicts communication. I think the film is so ingenious in its presentation of "future technologies" in a mundane context. The movie has aged so well; I think that's a pretty accurate representation of some video chatting I've done, even though it took more than 40 years to materialize.

It's pretty hyperbolic to call 2001 a dystopia, especially if they're referring to the apparent lack of enthusiasm that accompanied communication.

Yes, HAL went on a murdering spree, but if that's all the Rossmeier (the article's author) is talking about, then he's missing the point of 2001.

Anyway, I agree: it's an odd reference. I think 2001 is one of the best movies I've seen (no joke), so I have a few thoughts on the matter...

Beyond the temporal distance, there is the fact that the astronauts were under constant surveillance by HAL. Perhaps Frank Poole did not care to be demonstrative under the circumstances.