Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nether 4425 days ago
This is Malcolm Gladwell nonsense and not backed up by the fact that Chinese-Americans who learn English first (e.g. Nobel laureate Steven Chu) do just as well as their Chinese counterparts.
2 comments

But we're talking about an entire country in which most people don't speak English at all. If I have to tell my 55 year old aunt to go to www.hotmail.com then I'd have to spend half an hour describing what English letters to type.
I can imagine it's something like explaining how to change some obscure setting through a GUI interface over the phone, but significantly worse.

On one hand you have: "OK, do you see a button in the lower left? Click that. Now press "Options", then "Configure". What? You don't see those? Which button did you click? ..."

On the other hand you have: "OK, do you see the button that looks like a squiggly line? It's in the top-leftish corner, between the button that has a circle with a small line through it and a button that looks like a comb. Press that one three times..."

It's not about being good at math, just at memorizing numbers. I'm Chinese American and was considered to be "good-at-math" in grade school, but damned if I can remember long sequences of numbers. Maybe I should try thinking about them in Chinese.