Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by robmclarty 4537 days ago
Lol. I agree the argument is a bit misleading. Apple products can be considered to be just as confusing.

Apple Product Names:

- iPad - iPad 2 - iPad - iPad /w Retina - iPad Air

Which iPad do I buy!? I'm thinking, maybe, the iPad 2 because it must be the most current and advanced model :P
2 comments
oneeyedpigeon 4537 days ago
Admittedly, if you're the type of person who purely bases their purchasing decisions on the trailing number in a product name and whether it's bigger or smaller than that of an alternative, yes, this would be confusing. However, if you take other factors into account (price, weight, size, looks, maybe even - gasp - technical specifications) then it becomes a fair bit easier to determine which is the most current and advanced.
link
robmclarty 4537 days ago
The article was about how great Apple names things and how bad everyone else does. My point is that Apple's names aren't some brilliant miracle of nomenclature like the article makes them out to be.

Obviously if I'm going to drop $500+ I'm going to kick the tires and take the product for a spin around the block to see how it feels (and maybe even read its specs).

I think what Apple does do well, and which the article points out, is that they limit their offerings to a number I can count on one hand, the differences between each being obvious tradeoffs (e.g., performance vs. portability) which consumers can actually decide between. This empowers consumers, makes them feel good because they understand what's happening, and likely leads to increased sales.

link
josefresco 4537 days ago
The size, weight, and looks of the iPad have not changed dramatically since it's introduction which leaves consumers with the "trailing numbers" and gasp technical specs to differentiate each model. And we know how well "average" users can parse and compare technical specs.
link
coldtea 4537 days ago
>Which iPad do I buy!? I'm thinking, maybe, the iPad 2 because it must be the most current and advanced model :P

How about doing the same with all Sony models released from 2010 to 2014 then?

Because you're comparing stuff that just isn't there. When a person visits applestore.com or an Apple Store, he's only going to see the currently sold models, not the whole product history.

He might be momentarily confused that iPad 2 is older than the iPad Air, but that can be fixed with one glance at the price or specs, or a word from an employee.

The difference between some competitor names like HVZ-KM323 and HMH-23hiK? Not so much.

link