Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pdimitar 18 days ago
Point me at a laptop as small and quiet. Hell, let's forget weight. I'll gladly lug around 2.5kg machine if it almost never turns its fan on and is as compact.

Actually let's not care about compactness either. Can go up to 17". Just show me a truly quiet laptop.

You are misjudging me here. I'm moving back to Linux after using Macs for 7 years. My desktop Mac is soon going to be history. macOS makes too many choices for me that I dislike. We're not just talking stylistically or philosophically; those I can mostly get over if needed. We're talking objectively and technologically.

I want a good travel machine however. People look at you funny on meetups when your laptop starts blasting jet engines. Nobody is saying it out loud but you're becoming the odd one out and that has a social and career cost. (That's not even touching the fact that noisy machines stress me out and break my focus.)

I'll get a Neo for travel even if I hate giving Apple money. Because everyone else is two decades behind.
1 comments
makeitdouble 17 days ago
We could do the same exercise in reverse:

Point me at a laptop with a touch and pen support and detachable keyboard, within the 13" range and 260+ppi resolution, that can virtually run modern software and mid-tier games at workable speeds.

That's the bar my personal laptop clears, and no mac does. Should I be claiming that it has unbeatable hardware ?

PS: We've been in this for a very long time. Even during the PowerPC days, it was a meme to take a mac, adjust for exactly the same hardware specs and tout that the mac was unbeatable for the price. Thing is, having different hardware specs and tradeoffs is exactly the point of the PC market. I still feel great for the people that exactly fit the "one size fits all" offering, but getting a machine that perfectly fits one's needs is extremely valuable IMHO.

link
pdimitar 17 days ago
Sure but that's only a theoretical, as in, a non-existing argument. You don't get to tell me what I want in a laptop; I already stated it and stand by it.

"Unbeatable" comes from "satisfies all my hardware requirements". If you want to be difficult and try to grill me to append "...according to what I deem an important criteria" at the end of each sentence then that's a separate conversation, and one I'll refuse to have.

link
makeitdouble 16 days ago
"the Neo is competitive for basic office and media stuff" can be a better way to put it. I'd say the Surface Pro is a more competent but pricier jack of all trade.

There's so many ways to express the same points with not much more words. Especially when the article is about a machine that is a completely different league from the Neo.

link
pdimitar 16 days ago
> "the Neo is competitive for basic office and media stuff" can be a better way to put it.

Agreed in general, though in my case it would be something like this:

"The Neo is a great thin client through which you can hop around your entire infrastructure and work remotely in it, through the Neo."

Because that is my use-case for it. Travel but not having to work on a machine with 8GB RAM.

link