[Glohrischi]

I had a really fun day yesterday because anthropics limits on their normal 20$ subscription allowed me to play around for the whole day without hitting a limit.

Its 'production' code because its a small browser game which has very small to 0 requirements on security and being perfect but high requirements on 'ever even doing this' and 'fun'.

The code it generated hat 0 compiletime errors. I was able to descripe 10 things to do in one task and it just jugged along solving all of them.

This doesn't need to become so much better to be useful. Its already very useful for a lot ofuse cases like researchers which have to verify the math anyway but are not good in writing code for filtering their testdata, converting them and running it.

Small websites, fun projects, helper tools etc.

But while we speak, in the background stuff is still happening left and right. More compute, better algorithm, more RL etc.

We could already be at 95% at 'ai will take your coding job' without knowing because these 5% are so relevant.

[forlorn_mammoth]

> The code it generated hat 0 compiletime errors

And no spelling errors either!

Also,

> Really? What duplication did you actually find? I count a few small ones in buildMounts and ReadPrompt, maybe 20 lines or so, but hardly anything worthy of such an epithet

>> embedding-shape 1 hour ago | root | parent | next [–]

>>The duplication I'm seeing isn't just "same text repeated" but structural duplication. Doing a quick 5 minute look again just to give you some pointers; runtime.MountSpec construction in buildMounts, Workdir vs aux-dir mount-mode handling, repeated one-off mount append blocks, overlay detection and so on, the list goes on. Just those should account for 200+ lines.

If you don't see any errors or problems, is it because there aren't any problems to see, or because they take a trained eye to spot?

[Glohrischi]

I'm not a native english speaker and when i mentioned that i might use LLM for fixing spellings, people argued about the use of LLM. So spelling error yes/no?

I do not understand the quote you rference at all tbh?

[keybored]

I don’t see how “fun projects” and “take our jobs” fit together in any voluntary sentence.

[Glohrischi]

Firstly i wrote examples but also etc. so its more than just that. It is also refactoring, cicd pipelines and co.

2 years ago when I prompted something, it had compile time errors left and right. Took me 3-10 iterations to even get it running.

Now its one shoting a lot. Including websides, refactorings, etc.

The question is what is missing? How far are we that it can handle huge code bases vs. smaller ones? How far are we that it can comprehend the whole architecture and doesn't try to put a service in a wrong place just becaus the context is too small?

Mythos is 10 Trillion, that might be already pushing it.

95% might be not enough for someone in sense of "yeah i can't do the 95% and i can't do the 5% either the AI can do 100% or i still need Kevin with his knowledge even if its just for the last 5%"

[keybored]

What I’m saying is that I won’t do, as a hobby and for fun, something that helps strength train my chronic unemployment. That’s a me-issue.

[hiw2d]

"We could already be at 95% at 'ai will take your coding job' without knowing because these 5% are so relevant."

This is nonsense. Im not a SWE but a CEO, if that were true I'd be firing without a hitch. And yet this is not the activity we see. Why is that? Perhaps merely writing code is not the entire job.

[Glohrischi]

I wrote coding job. And its true for coding jobs.

Your Product Manager is not a coding job. Your Product Owner is not a coding job.

vibe-kanban exists you could already do a proper experiment letting your PO maintain a vibe-kanban board with proper requirements and see how an agent progresses.

But 5% is often enough wwhat breaks it. Doesn't help much when your PM, PO or CEO or CTO have no clue about coding harnesses, coding agents, coding platforms, LLMs etc.

[hiw2d]

I dont have PMs or POs in my firm fella.

Im hyper efficient. You clearly are not and are full of it.

If youre only doing 5%, you should only get paid for that. lol. Are you happy to take a salary drop?

[Glohrischi]

Whats wrong with you? Why the change of tone?

I'm a Cloud ARchitect with experience in coding (15 years) and infrastructure (10 years) and startup founder...

If you don't comprehend what i write, feel free to ask but don't be dick?

[chasd00]

the change in tone is because you're either dealing with a troll or the CEO of a one person, contract-for-hire, "company".

[keybored]

CEO makes fresh account to tell someone that writing code is not the entire job? I don’t buy it.