Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by java-man 54 days ago
Based in Florida (?), United States. Subject to the US surveillance laws and obligated not to report on government access requests, whether legal or illegal.

No thank you, Proton or Tuta would be a better alternative.

1 comments

This is definitely a fair concern, and something that we have thought thoroughly about, but let me clarify some things:

Our architecture makes jurisdiction less relevant than it would be for a traditional email provider. All email content, subjects, attachments, contacts, etc are encrypted client-side, locally, before they reach our servers, and you hold the keys, not us.

If we ever were to receive a legal request, we could only hand over encrypted blobs and routing metadata (sender/recipient addresses, timestamps), the same metadata any email provider in any country would have.

We maintain a warrant canary at https://astermail.org/notices/canary.txt, and we have a full transparency report at https://astermail.org/transparency. We have never received a secret government subpoena, national security letter, or a gag order to date.