Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by weregiraffe 239 days ago
Nobody has oral history from 7700 years ago.
3 comments

Of course they can, why not? The example in the article is really good and perfectly believable.

People at that time would wander around a lot in their everyday life, and it would be very easy to remember these small stories which are connected to the landscape. A father would tell his son when they were walking past this feature of the landscape, and the son would later tell his son and so on.

Why? Because they didn't have cell phones to scroll on while wandering, or a radio to listen to. And they weren't thinking about their mortgage or about primaries. When you live in a world like this, it is very easy to remember a bunch of unusual stories, and when they're connected to the landscape instead of to people, it is almost a guarantee that they will be passed on for generations.

Because of the game of Telephone.

Humans aren't capable of repeating stories without permutation.

That applies to the written word as well. You can never guarantee that your modern understanding of what a word means is the same as what the original writer meant.
Lol seen the homepage of the ABC? (Australian not American broadcaster).
I assume you're referring to this?https://www.abc.net.au/news/deeptime/
That's a really interesting site. Thanks for the tip.
I agree, but the linked article claims otherwise.
An unprovable assertion, I'll note. So: opinion.