[OtomotO]

This, so much this...

I signed up for Claude over a week ago and I totally regret it!

Previously I was using it and some ChatGPT here and there (also had a subscription in the past) and I felt like Claude added some more value.

But it's getting so unstable. It generates code, I see it doing that, and then it throws the code away and gives me the previous version of something 1:1 as a new version.

And then I have to waste CO2 to tell it to please don't do that and then sometimes it generates what I want, sometimes it just generates it again, just to throw it away immediately...

This is soooooooo annoying and the reason I canceled my subscription!

[brandon272]

> But it's getting so unstable. It generates code, I see it doing that, and then it throws the code away and gives me the previous version of something 1:1 as a new version.

I've had the same experience. Totally unreliable.

[actsasbuffoon]

I regularly have this happen:

1. Ask Claude to fix something

2. It fails to fix the issue

3. I tell it that the fix didn’t work

4. It reverts its failed fix and tells me everything is working now.

This is like finding a decapitated body, trying to bring it back to life by smooshing the severed head against the neck, realizing that didn’t bring them back to life, dropping the head back on the ground, and saying, “There; I’ve saved them now.”

[johnisgood]

Gosh, can't we get back to Sonnet 3.5 or whichever was the version around a year ago? It worked so well for me.

[jononor]

This happens to me a lot. Almost once per session now, and not even when things are complicated. The model also thinks it has done the changes. So it seems a UI/state bug, not on the model side.

[mh-]

I believe this is an issue with tool calling, similar to my complaint above about it refusing to use its search tool (or claiming that it did when I can see that it did not.)