Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by corin_ 5075 days ago
Would you rather pay considerably more to have an ad-free version? And even if yes, can you persuade their other readers to do that too?

Covering the cost of a service with both customer payment and advertising is... everywhere. Do you also get pissed off when you go to a cinema, watch TV, go to a sports game, ride on a bus, etc etc?
3 comments
rblackwater 5075 days ago
I would be willing to either pay more for something completely ad-free or not pay at all. I probably would not pay considerably more. How much extra does a magazine get from advertising? I thought it would be like three or four dollars per issue.

Yes I also do not enjoy being advertised to when watching a movie or TV, so I seldom do it. I don't feel as bad on the bus, although I'm not sure why, since as you point out it is roughly the same thing.

I think it's the presentation of ads in the midst of content VS ads off to the side on the bus.

Anyway, thank you for that thought-provoking comment.

link
corin_ 5075 days ago
Is the bus not the same as the magazine, where you can go "oh look an advert, I'll just ignore that and get back to my content"?

I'm not sure about the value of magazine adverts, I've never worked in print advertising,MIT even at a few dollars that would mean you have to pay double. If they raised prices to do that, the higher price could/would drive some people away, meaning you'd then have to pay more to cover those lost sales..

link
rblackwater 5074 days ago
I've been thinking about this, and I believe there is a distinction since on the bus I am paying for the conveyance, not the content, so at no point do I ever consciously look at the advertising. For a magazine, I am consciously reading the content and they are putting advertising where my attention is directed. It doesn't help that the advertisements in a magazine pad it out so it looks like it has more content than it would otherwise.

I think that is more like a bus that detours to certain shops instead of taking shorter routes. You'd be paying for the conveyance and they would be abusing that by taking your time to gain themselves more money.

link
pessimizer 5075 days ago
Ads wormed their way into the cinema slowly, and under loud protest.
link
wccrawford 5075 days ago
Actually, my first thought when I read the headline was, "Oh, then I might subscribe."

Unfortunately, they didn't really throw off the advertisers as I imagined. So no go.

link