[seabass-labrax]

The difference is that Elon Musk has not challenged scientific consensus by publishing revolutionary studies or conducting risky experiments, but rather by republishing inflammatory statements online. His actual achievements (including super-heavy rockets and electric cars) are largely independent from his unconventional views on vaccines, for instance.

You can't compare him to figures like Newton and Hooke, who made both their names and their living from science.

[edanm]

> You can't compare him to figures like Newton and Hooke, who made both their names and their living from science.

Not disagreeing with the rest of your post, just making a minor nitpick - didn't Newton actually spend most of his time on alchemy and at the Royal Mint? He definitely made his name from science (or math & science as I prefer to think of it). But his living? I don't know about that.

[seabass-labrax]

I'm no scholar of Newton's life, but I am aware that Newton became a professor soon after attaining his master's degree at Cambridge. I believe he kept this role for the rest of his life in addition to the later posts at the Royal Mint (which were supposed to be merely sinecures, but jobs that he nonetheless took rather more seriously on his own initiative). As for the alchemy, I think one can reasonably consider that science, as the modern principles of chemistry were still a couple of centuries off - Newton did at least conduct proper experiments, which is basis of the natural sciences.

All in all, I think that he certainly made his living from his success in science at first, even if he could have later maintained himself simply on his esteem and lofty networks at Cambridge.

[whywhywhywhy]

> publishing revolutionary studies

Just because you put it in PDF doesn't make it something more.

[whamlastxmas]

Elons success is in very large part due to challenging the status quo

[tordrt]

Whats his unconvential views on vaccines? I am not convinced he has any. Could not find anything obvious at leadt

[tim333]

I'm not aware of any. I think the author misinterpreted him with:

>Musk tweeted: "My pronouns are Prosecute/Fauci", thereby managing to simultaneously offend the LGBTQ community, express an antivaxx sentiment...

Musk actually explained he wasn't in to the pronoun stuff and:

>As for Fauci, he lied to Congress and funded gain-of-function research that killed millions of people. Not awesome imo.

ie. lab leak, not vax