Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by deliciousturkey 735 days ago
This is just not true. Only the Commission can propose new legislation. This very proposal also is quite aggressively pushed by the Commission (see for example the advertising campaign: https://noyb.eu/en/noyb-files-complaint-against-eu-commissio...).
4 comments

Specifically this is being pushed by Ylva Johansson [1] from Sweden, who has (reportedly) financial connections to the organisation Thorn which is hoping to sell this chat monitoring software.

[1]https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ylva_Johansson

> Only the Commission can propose new legislation.

That is a technicality relying on a shallow look at the word "propose". The commission frequently takes direction from the council when deciding what to focus on which leads to them "proposing" legislation. In this case the push for this has come from the Council and certain national governments combined with a particular commissioner.

The Commission agenda and mandate is set by the Council that nominates it, and periodically reviewed by the same Council. Items are set in meetings, the agenda of such meetings is typically public.

If the Commission pushes, it's because the Council told it to push.

And the Commission is formed by national governments.
The Commission is formed by commissioners, each of which has been nominated by a different nation's government. The Council consists of actual members of the national governments.

The third party that can't propose legislation but has to approve it (and which strongly opposed this) is the Parliament, which is directly elected.

No. The Commission is formed by the national governments and of commissioners.
OK, this is probably some nuance of the English language that I'm missing as a non-native speaker, but I meant that the people that make up the Commission are not part of the national governments. The people that are part of national governments each get to nominate one commissioner though, in addition to being part of the Council.