Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by peterhadlaw 824 days ago
Probably the most inhumane thing ever is having to make a recorded video of yourself answering personal life questions (presumably to be reviewed by a human from HR) only to actually be processed by an algorithm.
3 comments

How about "Dont send us a resume! We aren't a traditional company. Make a crazy video showing us your personality and why you'd be the best person for the job. Costumes are a bonus."
It doesn't end at hiring. At one place I worked, the CEO got new hires in a room and "spontaneously" asked them to tell an embarrassing story about themselves one by one, to break the ice. People were very uncomfortable but did it. Nobody was having fun, it was pretty cringe. Then it was the CEO's turn (she went last), and she told the most flattering "embarrassing" you could imagine, which was basically just a huge flex about her life and opportunities.

Some company leaders just like to humiliate the people who work for them because they can.

I’ve been in such a situation but I don’t do group stupid so got up and left.
Same here. CIO and my boss look up and I'm gone. My boss blows up my phone begging me to come back. Ruined my career there. My colleagues literally gushed over me and said they wished they had the courage to leave also. It was traumatizing for most involved.
you tanked your career because you couldn't do a simple, if silly and lame, group ice breaker thing?

like, just make some shit up. this shouldn't even be a thing. "I never learned how to ride a bike" or "I peed my pants while skydiving" or something. fake a couple of laughs, and then think about how much beer you're going to have after work.

There’s a Black Mirror episode somewhere in here akin to the Hunger Games.
I mean, peddling the bike to keep your vim session going might be good for many of us. Well, at least me.
Peddling to keep it closed more like.
It's straight up dystopian.
All hail our new AI overlords. "Meet the new boss. Same as the old boss".
SEO for resumes has been a thing for at least a decade. It’s dystopian and dehumanizing. You can only imagine how bad it is going to get when AI gets to screen, interview, and hire; totally autonomously. I’m sure companies are begging for this: cutting their entire recruiting budget would surely return at least 0.01% to the almighty shareholders.
This has been the case since professional HR came into being in tech, and people (mainly women) with no domain background were given a major role to play in shortlisting candidates.
The gender comment feels unnecessary.
An empirical fact though.
Is that really a thing happening these days? Sounds horrible.
Oh, it's been happening since 2020. I was offered a few of these HireVues, but I could never finish any because the experience of speaking to a screen like it's a person is so dehumanizing. I believe one of them was from General Motors.
Wow, it's easy for me to say in my current situation but I think if I had to do that I would start considering another line of work.
If they'll dehumanize you in the hiring process, what would it be like to work there?