Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jug 867 days ago
This sounds like what Microsoft has tried but failed to do in numerous iterations for two decades: OFS (Cairo, unreleased predecessor to Windows 95), Storage+ (SQL Server 7.0), RFS (SQL Server 2000), Exchange Webstore, Outlook LIS, WinFS, and finally Microsoft Semantic Engine.

All projects were either cancelled, features cut, or officially left in limbo.

It's a pretty remarkable piece of Microsoft history as it has been there on the sidelines since roughly post-Windows 3.11. The reason they returned to it so often was in part because Bill Gates loved the idea of a more high level object storage that, like this, bridges the gap between files and databases.

He would probably have loved this kind of technology part of Windows -- and indeed in 2013, he cited the failure of WinFS as his greatest disappointment at Microsoft, that it was ahead its time and that it would re-emerge.

1 comments

>> and indeed in 2013, he cited the failure of WinFS as his greatest disappointment at Microsoft,

Failing to capture any of the mobile handset market while missing out almost entirely on search and social media businesses would be higher on my list if I were in BG's shoes.

Intellectually though, I could see the WinFS failure as being more disappointing. If it had worked, local computing would have been completely different. Much like BeFS, WinFS (as marketed) would have introduced many new ways to interact with your computer and data.

Having a bigger presence in mobile and social would have been more lucrative, but from a CS geek point of view, the failure of WinFS might have been more stinging.

Speaking of mobile handset markets, does SeaweedFS support Android?
Microsoft has never been good in either consumer electronics or advertising (social media).

MS carved out economic rent on business with Windows and Office, Apple actually failed at that.

"Gaming is now the third largest business at Microsoft." After Office and Azure, before Windows.

https://www.theverge.com/2024/1/30/24055445/microsoft-q2-202...

Sure. But windows was/is the loss leader for that. No gaming or office without windows. Even Azure benefits from it as it ties into Active Directory with Azure AD. This makes it a completely integrated story. So that they are even still making money off of windows directly is just a direct benefit.
It is amazing how sticky auth is.
Did those happen under Gates?