Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by jaipilot747 1120 days ago
When would I use Baremaps versus something like GeoServer?
2 comments

Hi, author here, Baremaps aims to create an open and easily extensible vector map, inspired by OpenStreetMap Carto. The goal is to provide a high-quality base map for the planet. Since we use PostGIS as a storage backend, you can extend it with your own layers and data.
I hope your planning on going beyond what Carto does. Baremaps currently doesn't render highway=busway either, leading to awkward gaps in the map. It's an accepted tag supported in every renderer except Carto (look at OsmAnd or Organic Maps for instance), because the two or three active maintainers remaining (having lost a number of maintainers in the past two years) don't like the tag. Carto has pretty much stagnated despite its past achievements.

As the default renderer for openstreetmap.org, Carto is currently an embarrassment for OpenStreetMap.

Thank you for describing this issue, I created an issue on GitHub to track it. The fact that OpenStreetMap Carto is used in the OpenStreetMap documentation greatly accelerated our styling process (e.g. https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Map_features). That being said, it is a loose port, and I hope we will soon be able to provide other derivatives, such as a positron style.
Are coordinates stored in Web Mercator?
Yes, as the tiles are created directly from Postgis, reprojecting the coordinates would take too much time.
Dear lord why would you use GeoServer for anything in 2023
What would you use instead?