Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gregjor 1180 days ago
I can only guess at the motivation behind this question.

"Happy" doesn't describe an innate attribute or constant emotional state. It describes how you or I react to experiences. We can't predict or control everything that affects us, but we can choose how we interpret and react. We call a person "happy" if they seem to take things in stride, find something positive, not get anxious or angry. I think feeling happy, or content, most of the time comes from not expecting the world and the other people in it to behave the way I might like them to or think they should. I can choose not to worry and make myself anxious over things I can't control. I can decide not to let someone manipulate or control my emotional reactions. Everyone can make those decisions.

Buddhism teaches that we all suffer as part of living, and desire causes that suffering. It follows that reducing desire may reduce suffering and lead to contentment and happiness. Someone may desire material things, a romantic partner, friends. Many people desire that other people behave in a certain way, or that the world should treat them fairly. When their desires don't get fulfilled they feel disappointed, anxious, sad, angry.

Absurdism offers the idea that life has no deep meaning, the universe doesn't care about us, and no deity or higher power watches over us and intervenes in our affairs. Some people find that prospect frightening and depressing (thus spiritual beliefs and religion). Others find it freeing and comical -- if we have no purpose we can choose to enjoy our brief lives as much as possible.

A happy person accepts and adapts to what comes their way. They don't indulge in useless emotions like worry, guilt, regret. They change their situation as much as they can to enjoy life more.

Since "happy" describes how a person interprets and reacts to the world, and people who seem happy come from all cultures and traditions and walks of life, I don't think asking what a day, week, or year in such a person's life looks like will give any useful information. You can't make yourself feel happier by brooding over how people you perceive as happy live their lives.

1 comments

Such thought patterns can equally easily lead further into depression. Indeed often one needs a motivating goal to get out of a depressive phase and as soon as everything becomes "meaningless", then no goal will be strong enough.
Everything can't become meaningless because what we call meaning and purpose describe subjective interpretations, not inherent properties. My children mean a lot to me, but the meaning comes from me and my interactions with my children, not from a quality they possess (which is why my children don't mean anything to most people). It follows that nothing can "become meaningless," it can only cease to mean something in relation to you or me.

We have to find our own meaning and purpose in life, not look outside ourselves. I assume people reading my comment understand the distinction between higher purpose or meaning in the sense of the world at large, the universe, or the hereafter if you prefer, and what each of us finds personally meaningful or purposeful.

For myself, I found meaning and purpose from having children to raise. If I didn't have children I might find purpose in accumulating wealth, or finding a partner I enjoy spending time with, or traveling to see the world. Even hanging out with friends and laughing has some meaning, just not likely a cosmic meaning.

If a person needs to feel their life and (subjective) interpretation of their place and purpose in the world has importance and meaning outside of their subjective experience to stave off depression they should seek professional help. To imagine that what one does has significance, importance, and meaning beyond subjective experience seems like a symptom of delusion or narcissism.

I agree. I am currently stuck in a rut where everything seems meaningless, and I can’t find the motivation to do much of anything.

I desperately yearn for a meaning/purpose to serve as a source of internal motivation…

Up until now, the only thing that has been a “motivation” for me is a fear of failure, so that’s what I rely on to get anything done.

What about the pleasure of learning something new? Of accomplishing something for yourself? Solving a problem, or making a new thing? Or making yourself a better friend, partner, spouse, friend? Enjoying time with people you care about? Those things can give you a feeling of purpose and meaning.

I think the problem comes from expecting to find a larger purpose or meaning. Few of us will change the world significantly. Rid yourself of the idea that your life must have a greater purpose than satisfying yourself and the people you care about.

For example, too many people put a lot of effort into social media status in the form "likes" or "karma." What actual meaning does that have? What purpose does it serve, aside from attention-seeking and narcissism? When people spend their time on getting attention and status display their ego gets crushed when that attention doesn't come, or goes away. Wouldn't enjoying a walk on the beach give more pleasure, even if it serves no purpose beyond relaxation and contemplation?

You have to start with yourself, to find meaning and purpose for yourself in how you treat yourself, and then how you interact with other people. You can't start by hoping to find a greater purpose or meaning in life and feeling down and useless until that happens.