Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by stopping 1183 days ago
Over the years my opinion on light trucks has shifted from ambivalence to seething resentment. The main reason is that I now live in an area where large vehicles have become increasingly disruptive to normal living:

1) Side streets that prioritize street parking (e.g. streets with multi-family housing) mean that a poorly-parked truck is literally impossible to see around when you're driving a smaller vehicle. Exiting an apartment driveway is frequently a precarious maneuver when you can't clearly see traffic coming in one or both directions. Heaven forbid there's a bicyclist obstructed from view.

2) Headlight elevation blinds other drivers, especially those in shorter vehicles. If you're being blinded from behind at night, you have to slow down to let them pass, or else your mirrors become useless or even actively dangerous to look at.

3) Blind spots in newer light trucks are horrendously large, as indicated in the video. Many drivers are not aware of the blind spot to the front-right side of the cab and are at risk of being PITed by an inattentive driver changing lanes into them.

4) Echoing the point about parking infrastructure. Being unable to park these sorts of vehicles in standard spaces and garages means that many of these end up parked on the street where inconvenience to other drivers is maximized.

The only way a driver can completely mitigate these problems is to simply join in the Bigger Vehicle arms race, to the detriment of all other drivers and pedestrians.

7 comments

Typical American went to France/Nice for a week. It is astonishing how many more small cars can fit and move around roads than a bunch of SUVs.

The "personal space" of an SUV is gigantic, while driving around in small cars you have a vastly better sense of the road and people around you. If everyone is driving cars, your visibility of the road and traffic is far better because you can see through the windshields of cars in front of you.

AND THOSE GODDAMN HEADLIGHTS.

When the human race was first getting mainstream education on global warming in the late 1990s, the United States of America collectively decided to basically double the weight of its vehicles, and squander engineering wonders that vastly increased the fuel economy of vehicles.

If the demand and desire for these is really so great, slap a $10,000 surcharge + $1,000/year fee on their ownership and redirect all of it to BEVs and alt energy.

They should also slap a $9000 surcharge on small cars because I'm sure the owners would want to make a contribution to help stop climate change.
... and here we are, people, the American SUV mindset wide open for all to see!

See the incredible myopic vision! The complete lack of tone awareness! An utter lack of sense of their surroundings!

All in one comment!

And the best thing: That's exactly how SUVs are driven! It's such a sublime comment.

I'm not American nor do I drive American SUVs.
On #2, it's not just headlight elevation -- it's bumper height. Imagine that truck on 44s with a 4" lift kit and 2" body lift crashing into a standard car. If you guessed that their bumper would go through the rear window of whatever they crashed into, you'd be right. At worst, they'd shear the top off the car they crashed into, possibly decapitating the occupants.

A common reason to lift trucks is to fit larger tires. Larger tires roll further with each revolution. Many trucks with larger tires DO NOT also have larger brakes. That makes braking performance worse. Running soft mud tires on the highway and not changing them when they inevitably wear down after just a few thousand miles also yields worse performance. Combine this with the added top-heavy nature, suspension with more travel, worse visibility, and "king of the road" attitudes that many lifted truck drivers bring, and it's not hard to see that this is a recipe for disaster.

It's literally illegal in many places, but the enforcement is so lax that everyone gets away with it https://www.motortrend.com/features/0601st-truck-lift-kit-st...

I really wish that at least California would crack down on vehicle inspections and actually start refusing to register these vehicles, fine the owners, and make them reverse the mods or scrap the vehicle. If you want to build an off-road Tonka truck, get a side by side which is way more capable anyway, or get something with adjustable suspension and swap out the wheels and tires.

Lastly, it's also infuriating how many vehicle owners, but especially truck drivers, remove their catalytic converters and/or mod their diesel truck to not require Diesel exhaust fluid. When they register the vehicle for use on public roads, they agree to adhere to emissions standards. They then renege on this agreement. It's only fair, then, to disallow them to operate that vehicle on public roads, to stop them from polluting the public air that we all must breath at a rate far beyond what they agreed to. I don't wager that many folks appreciate hearing their loud exhaust at all hours of the day, either. We have a few neighbors in our suburb with big loud trucks and for some reason they love flooring them every time as they turn the corners in the subdivision. I'd love to see all those vehicles get crushed for repeated inspection failures, and that's probably the level we'd need to go to given the widespread flouting of the law that we currently see.

I drive a car that operates on maxwells equations rather than burning dinosaur juice, and I understand electricity a lot better than those fire chariot Rube Goldberg machines. Why do people remove the catalytic converter, diesel exhaust fluid? (I have to admit I don’t really know what purpose they serve either, IC stuff has been too complex for me to fully grok)
Emission standards require you to maintain the car as it was sold to you.

So with DEF that means that since the car was sold with a DEF injection mechanism the car's computer will not allow the car to drive once you're out of DEF, as that will bump up the emissions.

As far as I know it kill performance, but you'll wanna have a spare bottle at the ready.

Catalytic converters on the other hand are much more impactful. They definitely reduce performance. And if you run rich you'll wear it out. So people cut them out.

California should massively increase their checks. Like pull people over for loud pipes. That would help a lot.

But you know, those people go to the smog shops that are open after working hours. And guess what, CA's government only checks them during working hours...

Catalytic converters are not really impacting performance most of the time, at least in terms of power. There are some efficiency losses from the restriction, but the net result is much cleaner exhaust. At peak power there is some reduction due to the converter, but it has been completely swamped by improvements in power density, so it isn't something anybody should be worried about. If you aren't running at peak power, the losses don't really matter.
I totally agree. These trucks have started to make me actively angry.
You shouldn't let it affect you. I would advise you to look into meditation, or at the least cannabis.
> 2) Headlight elevation blinds other drivers, especially those in shorter vehicles. If you're being blinded from behind at night, you have to slow down to let them pass, or else your mirrors become useless or even actively dangerous to look at.

Being blinded by headlights is a problem for me, but getting blinded from behind is a side issue. The big problem is getting blinded from ahead by oncoming traffic going the other way. This isn't a matter of the lights being mounted too high either. They're either aimed too high or they're just ridiculously bright.

I don't understand why cars are getting made this way.

Simple. Humans are not rational creatures. It's like in high school... people prefer to chasing what appears "cool" or whatever makes them feel powerful, or what will meet the approval of the in-group, or whatever it is they want. Ergo, they run on emotion over logic. It's why, for example, a lot of cars nowadays have low profile tires - they "look cool", even though they are worse than taller tires for typical road conditions. Then you have the fact that, all people are also (to varying degrees, but ultimately/inevitably) short sighted and self-centered, and horrible decisions get made all the time.
There is no reason why anyone needs more that 64k of RAM.

GPUs use too much power, people just want to play games because they want to feel some emotion. Is not valid because it is not based on logic.

Hence we should ban GPUs and only allow on board graphics. The physical constraints of integrated typically mean that the power usage of such setups is naturally limited, and people won't be able to play games for silly emotional reasons because the frame rates would be too low.

5) Many owners replace the mufflers with “mufflers”, dramatically increasing the noise. Many of them sound like the engine is venting straight into the air with no sound dampening at all. You can hear these things at night easily a mile away, loud enough to wake you up or have to rewind if you’re watching something.

I’m not even talking about coal rollers, which are their own special breed. The noise makers are extremely common and seem to be getting more popular.

Yes, can confirm. I have a 3" straight pipe direct from the turbo. The turbo acts as the muffler. I've heard a diesel without the turbo or muffler and it sounds like a bulldozer on meth.

However with just the turbo, at least on a 4.2L straight six, it sounds very nice (to me at least). Given the ability to breath and get the great away from the engine quickly the turbo can kick in earlier, mine is at 1500rpm or less. Gives more responsive power and cooler running. The turbo whistle sounds very nice.

This is referred to as “straight piping” in the car community, and you are correct it’s basically replacing the entire exhaust system with a straight pipe from the engine to the back. Even very weak Honda’s can be absurdly loud with this.
Its retardedly obnoxious without at least a turbo or resonator.
"blinded from behind at night".

I don't drive much, but every car I have ever driven (50 years with a driver's license) has had a little toggle on the rear-view mirror to put it into night-time mode. Is that insufficient?

It's actually the side mirrors which are the problem. I tend to glance at them frequently to maintain situational awareness, but that good habit is punished when a vehicle with elevated lights simply hovers in the lane next to you. Many times I have to actively adjust the mirror to a useless position just to keep from accidentally blinding myself.
Some people just love complaining cos they have so little going on in their life.
You should try meditation. It's quite helpful for calming yourself and becoming more at peace with the world and people around you.