Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Vibgyor5 1315 days ago
The fact that you are getting so many response arguing that "its just your social circle/just one anecdotal data", when the parent pro-iPhone comment is exactly the same anecdotal evidence speaks volume about pro-iPhone bias that plenty of North American users may have.

Some of the arguments are straight up bonkers for me - for instance, "iMessage is more secure." Is it? Apple is a US-based firm and subject to the whims of US laws and governmental intrusion.

In my circle - and I have lived in both Europe and Asia - we heavily use Telegram. I find it to be far more favorable experience than iMessage. UX and interoperatibility between platforms is far more superior and it runs flawlessly - doesn't matter whether it is a flagship Apple/Samsung device or a cheap Xiaomi phone. Or PC/Mac/Linux for that matter.

2 comments

You realize that by citing your “circle uses Telegram” when even a cursory internet search will show you and your friends are in the minority, will quickly reveal how small your bubble is?
My cursory internet search shows me that it has 700 Million active users worldwide - that number is not "small" in my opinion. One of the most popular messaging apps in Asia, Europe, CIS countries, LatAm etc. I think you just prove my point of there being an North American bias against other messaging platforms fwiw
iMessage is more secure at least if both ends have iCloud backups off.
iMessage and iPhones being 'more secure' is simply not true. I know it's being thrown around a lot, but e.g. Pegasus famously had zero-click exploits for iMessage.
iMessage is (at least somewhat) end to end encrypted and SMS is not.
SMS is very uncommon in much of Europe.

I'm feeling you are assuming that the alternative to iMessages in Europe is SMS. It's not. The alternative is WhatsApp, Telegram, Signal, Facebook Messenger, etc.

Signal > WhatsApp > iMessage > Telegram > Facebook Messenger > SMS
Is this how you estimate people in Europe do rank alternatives, or just how you think they should?
>WhatsApp > ... > Facebook Messenger

why? They're both end to end encrypted but owned by meta.