Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by hiharryhere 1371 days ago
The new Hummer EV is over 4 tons and does 0-100km/h in around 3 seconds.

Between the obvious danger per the article, there’s also lots of extra wear on roads, particularly small residential ones.

Lots of external costs.

3 comments

I'm not worried about those as much as the midsize and up SUV's, there will be very few Hummer EV's on the road statistically but mid size SUV's have become almost the standard American car.
Well, I live in the burbs and have a kid in his carseat in the back, plus stroller and groceries. Not to mention I'm a rather large man and when we last looked for cars I literally couldn't fit into a lot of them, I need more space. Even more, great gas mileage and reliability, and very safe. "Compact SUVs" or whatever they call the Subaru Forester now and it's ilk are exactly perfect for my family, especially with another kid on the way.
At least in Europe, 10 years ago you would have bought a family van. Nothing in this list of requirements says you need truck like features of an SUV.
> 10 years ago you would have bought a family van.

Fellow European here, we don't have kids but we were thinking at maybe getting a second dog, which made me look for a possible car replacement (we now have a 15+ year-old small hatchback). After some searching and calculating I found out that the "usefulness" of cars for my purported task (to transport two dogs in the back) can be summarized like this (in decreasing order): vans -> station wagons/estates -> SUVs/CUVs.

Unfortunately vans are on their out, I can't really understand the reason why (the VW Sharan will cease production this year, Ford C-Max ceased production back in 2019 etc), station wagons are also not feeling good, almost every car company is betting the house on SUVs/CUVs, which is a trend I don't like at all, because you get to pay more money for less utility.

They might come back, the VW id buzz is the first and cheaper options from other manufacturers will likely follow.

A quick review https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=51fyxgcVrKM

Agreed, where are all the MPVs going? We have a Cmax grande and it has more space than most SUVs. It even has better head and leg room.
I don’t know what kind of van you have in mind but there are plenty of vans in the US that are actually more powerful and heavy than a SUV. A Chrysler Voyager has 100 more hp and weighs about 900 lbs more than a Forester.
The vans don't pretend to be built for off-road, so they have better steering and lower gas mileage (both due to lower suspention and to lower weight).
Is this true? The van mentioned, the Chrysler Voyager, gets about 22mpg. The Subaru Forester (mentioned elsewhere as an example SUV) gets about 28mpg. The Forrester is about 3600 pounds, vs. 4300 pounds for the Voyager.
For two kids? Not even a van, just a station wagon.
My wife, kid in a car seat, and I recently went on a two weeks vacation in our VW Polo, baby stroller, disassembled om changing table and two weeks worth of luggage included. Granted, the car was jam-packed, but it makes me think you could get the things you listed to fit in a smaller car.
Never mind that even a larger european car like a citroën berlingo is wildly smaller than most american SUVs.
On the outside, cars like the berlingo offer so much more room on the inside than even large SUVs it's not even funny. Goes to show that many of the "I need a large car because I have a family" arguments, are really more about looking big from the outside, not so much about internal practicalities.
Do people actually buy berlingos to drive their family? I thought they were more intended to transport items / tools
My family got a Toyota Granvia. It fit 2 parents, 4 kids, 2 dogs, any strollers backpacks etc that we needed just fine.

Hell, my whole family went around the South Island on holiday in it for a whole month and it was just fine.

Cultural differences I guess. If you're an American you _need_ an SUV, I get it.

I guess I'm confused. The Granvia is about 5700 lbs and gets about 20 mpg. The Forrester is about 3600 lbs and gets 28 mpg. Why choose the Granvia?
NZ has different vehicles available to other countries. This was about 15 years ago or so. And a family of 6 plus several dogs and luggage capability.

I'm sure they could have maybe picked a smaller vehicle as well but economics also come into it - it was a secondhand Japanese import (NZ gets a lot of those, in fact when I was a kid we found yen coins still hidden underneath the seats) so it was gotten on the cheap as well.

You can't legally drive the hummer EV in Switzerland on your standard license (B permit) . The max weight allowed is 3500 kg. I doubt we will see this vehicle Europe for sale.
It can't legally drive on some small residential roads.
I'd like to see a source for that. It's wide, but it's still within federal limits.
Many residential neighborhoods have around a 3-ton vehicle weight limit (some go by axle count.) This was designed to stop semi-truck towing trailers from parking in neighborhoods. I lived in one and got chewed out when my OTR cousin stopped in for a night with his whole rig.
I would expect such a low limit to be relatively rare. It precludes a lot of regular vehicles -- everything from a basic UPS delivery truck to almost any regular pickup bigger than a Toyota Tacoma. A Hummer EV has a similar GVWR to an F250, and considerably lower than a typical F350, which are common residential vehicles (for better or worse).
Ford F-250 is 3 tons [1]. A one ton difference from the Hummer EV.

[1]https://www.ford.com/trucks/super-duty/models/f250-xlt/

An F250 generally has a GVWR of 9900, which is essentially 5T. It could be spec'd with a 12400 limit, but most are not. Far more common on an F350, though, to see 13000+.

I expect you're talking about curb weight. 6500 pounds for a gasser F250 is pretty typical, a bit north of 7000 for a diesel (which is 3.5T). But it's impractical to go by curb weight, the real number is GVWR. Can't tell what someone might be carrying and it all goes to the road.

> It precludes a lot of regular vehicles -- everything from a basic UPS delivery truck to almost any regular pickup bigger than a Toyota Tacoma

For someone from Europe this sentence is insane. Calling a truck heavier than 3 tones a regular vehicle is just mindboggling. In most (all?) of Europe you need a special license to drive a vehicle that is over 3.5 tonnes.

I would assume that the enforcement is very selective. Noone wants to weigh your car but if you drive a semi to your driveway they can ticket it
Marques Brownlee mentioned the car is illegal on some of his local roads because they have a 4 ton weight limit and the car weighs 9,046lbs.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TFdX6zL5h8Q&t=95s

10 Tonnes for a consumer vehicle anyone can buy and drive? Wow!
9000 pounds is 4.5 tons.
cries in metric