Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by rmc 5324 days ago
the treatment Alan Turing went through to "cure" his homosexuality. Whilst I had previously thought this only to be barbaric acts by small minded people, the report suggested some of the medics genuinely thought that this science could actually change him and be a force for good.

Yes there was attempts to turn homosexuals into heterosexuals, and they failed. There is amble scientific evidence, as a result of these abuses, that sexual orientation can't be changed.

1 comments

Could you please present your "am[p]le scientific evidence [...] that sexual orientation can't be changed".

I'll present an anecdote which, amongst several I've seen/heard, suggests to me that you're wrong in your assertion.

"On Freddie Mercury's Sexuality

'I think it was an undiscussed thing for a long time. The truth of the matter is nobody should care. Why should anyone care what sexual persuasion people have? It's about the music, and Freddie would have been the first to say that. He never hid the fact that he was turned on by men instead of by women, but strange enough, I don't think it was always the case. Because in the early days, we used to share rooms. So in the early days, I know who Freddie slept with, and they weren't men, but I think it gradually changed. And I have no idea how these things work, but it wasn't really anybody's business but his, and we never talked about it as if it were important. Why should it be important? We just made music together.'"

quoted from http://m.npr.org/news/front/128935865?singlePage=true

Could you please present your "am[p]le scientific evidence [...] that sexual orientation can't be changed".

I do not have scientific studies, and do not know off hand if there are scientific studies. But there are loads of people who went through these 'treatments', and it didn't work.

And there are plenty of gay men who would have slept with women when they were younger. Especially in the 1960s/70s UK. Just look at all the married, right wing coversative politicans who are caught with male prostitutes.

So in short your claim is anecdotal and there isn't any scientific evidence you know of (nevermind ample)?

Just that I have heard people personally state they have changed their orientation, by choice, both from homo- to heterosexual and vice-versa.