Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by greatartiste 1470 days ago
I never thought I would say this but LinkedIn seems to have gone even further downhill than it was a few years ago. You know things are bad when even the low end recruiters seem to have left the platform. These days 90% of the contacts/connect requests I receive are from dodgy pension "advisors" trying to get their hands on my pension pot cash.
4 comments

Further downhill than secretly installing an IMAP proxy on your phone and hijacking all your email to go through it in a way that destroyed all TLS security to your real mail server? Impressive...
That is a separate, standalone app, not the regular LinkedIn app
This doesn't excuse the fact that the company did this.
wait what?
I hadn’t heard of this either, but incredibly it turns out to be true: https://engineering.linkedin.com/mobile/linkedin-intro-doing...
Though, I was thinking that same sort of technology might come in handy for people that wanted to have encrypted email, without having to use a special encrypted email app: proxy through an app that did the encryption and decryption, but didn't store anything.
Yeah [1], and that's not even mentioning that the motivation behind those questionable "engineering" decisions was to be able to read and modify all your emails, helpfully injecting linkedin content into them.

[1] https://threatpost.com/linkedin-intro-app-equivalent-to-man-...

No I must admit that is even lower than I thought they were capable of , yet somehow doesn't surprise me.
Not directly related, whenever I get a new connection request, it is hard to tell if a person is real. Particularly if I don't know them first hand. The job history can be fake and profile photo generated by some GAN. It sucks but yeah, then later on they pitch something to you.
Why would you consider a connection from somebody you have not worked with?
I was early on a team that was > 100 people when I left years ago There's lots of assymetric memories of relationships, especially for people that joined in my last 6-12 months.

I'm sure a GAN picture that looked like a strong team member with a close-but-not-the-same name and lots of connections to people I knew well would fool me.

Also, the cost to me incorrectly friending such a person is much lower than missing a strong hire or new job opportunity.

Edit: Also, as someone hiring, you can't even reasonably ban people for this stuff. Some crappy recruiter database integration startup occasionally merges me with a coworoker, then spams out the fake profile. I've had my own company try to poach me before.

Linkedin should randomly send people made-up requests. They could collect statistics on the gullibility or neediness of the person and sell it!
Yeah it's a good question, most of mine are direct or recruiters. You have someone with "franchise" in their title, guess what... you get pitched a franchise. Idk what I was thinking.

edit: part of it in my rationale is "being nice" but yeah I mostly use LinkedIn to get a job

Recruiters typically have pro memberships meaning they can message you directly without being connected to you.
Yeah I mean I'm not searching for them, they're asking to connect to me

edit: ratio is about 25% recruiters

was interesting though I recently accepted a new role and out of the 30+ talks in a month about 95%+ were LinkedIn. The conversion for me was 10% actual interview phase, then where I actually got a job was Hired. -- some jobs wrong tech or I was not qualified for

LinkedIn is replete with fake accounts. Look at the array of bimboes lined up down the right side of the page at any given moment, all "recruiters."
Yes I'm seeing those as well. The pictures are just a little to perfect & the job history non existent.
Remember that huge hack that started when that person accepted a LinkedIn request. I forgot which hack it was.
wait what?
I could be wrong, but I think the story was contained here [0], where a chilean programmer was targeted through a LinkedIn face account set by north korean hackers.

[0] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2021/04/26/the-incredible...

There was also "Operation Socialist" [1] where the UK's GCHQ with the aid of the NSA hacked Belgacom, via phishing linkedin emails. Darknet Diaries also had an episode on it.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Socialist

I think this is the one. I read it in Darknet Diaries too but I thought it was a Chinese hacker.
Where else do you think people are going for informal networking / keeping up with old contacts?

(Ie just the messaging part)