Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by chopin 1511 days ago
I'd hire this guy if only being for this frank about his mistake. He owned it and that is what I would look for.

After deletion, what should he have done? Postpone the go-live? That's often not a a cost-effective option. As for a risk-analysis the worst what could happen was deletion of the remaining videos. I don't think that that makes big difference in this situation. And to do the right thing, you have to have the infrastructure in place, if you are in a hurry. I doubt that's the case for a 10 heads shop.

4 comments

Agree 100%. Acknowledged mistake, moved forward to find a solution. Reflected on lessons learned. Shared valuable lesson.

To me this indicates intelligence, competence, integrity, grit and generosity. TechnicL proficiency is much easier to come by than integrity, grit and generosity. I would trust the author to deliver on commitments.

Aye, this is how you learn and make sure it doesn't happen again.

I did a similar thing ~20 years ago when I first started my career, accidentally deleting a production database because I thought I was working on the test database.

I owned it, learned lessons from it, and it's never happened again.

Owning the mistake would be fine if he did that - he did'nt. He blamed the company he was contracting for. That's a big no from me
It's as if we read different articles. He literally writes that he made "A series of mistakes that could've probably been easily prevented."
I'm sorry if it came off like that. The mistake in this case was completely mine (bad code and bad testing). The detour on the other two companies was mostly because this way of deleting/recovering stuff should've probably been avoided in the first place, other than that I'm absolutely not blaming anyone else!
Don't worry about all that - there isn't a developer worth their salt that hasn't made a mistake. But I'd consider having this blog post and HN post retracted purely for future internet checks. It isn't a reflection on you, and your honesty is fantastic. But there is a lot to be said about using a pseudonym when it comes this close to your employers
I'd probably make your github profile private for a while as well. Or at least removing your real name from it.
Agreed. But I’d also fire him from this job.
Doesn't make sense. Their employer literally paid them to learn from their mistake.

Now, you think they should be fired? So that another employer rips the benefits of that learning experience.

"Recently, I was asked if I was going to fire an employee who made a mistake that cost the company $600,000. No, I replied, I just spent $600,000 training him. Why would I want somebody to hire his experience?"

-- Thomas J. Watson

For having got into a sticky situation and out of it?