Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by luis8 1568 days ago
Uber does the same thing. I noticed this one time when a friend was asking for the same ride. He has a basic credit card and i have a platinum amex card. My ride was 40% higher for the same trip
1 comments

How the fuck is that even legal?
Why would it not be? I’m not trying to be snarky. Under what law would that be illegal? Charging different people different prices for the same thing is perfectly legal so long as it’s not due to that person being a member of a protected class (race, sex, etc.).
Certain cards are very popular with certain demographics.

I would not do something as stupid using cards to discriminate pricing.

Now of course, we live in a society where the courts would never actually make that link, so you can argue I'd be a bad leader leaving money on the table like that...

But I'd say that's more a problem with our system than anything.

I'm pretty sure it is more than that. I mentioned in a comment below this one that they probably use my destinations as a proxy to asses my income and how much I'm willing to pay for a ride
Your legal case would pretty fast turn into bizarre hate speech:

”They’re charging people using the costco mastercard more!”

”Yeah, and?”

”Well, everyone knows that the jews love costco, and you can’t discriminate against an ethnic minority!”

Why?

Cash app targets underbanked people... guess what demographics are underbanked: https://www.bcg.com/publications/2021/unbanked-and-underbank...

So guess who they market heavily to: https://trapital.co/2020/03/18/how-hip-hop-helped-cash-app-g...

It's not racist, but it does make people look at uncomfortable truths about equality...

Because it’s likely not true or the full story.
Why would i lie? I'm pretty sure they also use my destinations to asses my income and factor that into how much i'm willing to pay for a ride
People have been accusing Uber of this ever since it started and Uber has categorically denied that it's doing this [1] "We may price routes differently based on our understanding of demand patterns, not individual riders."

And this entire time, nobody has generated definitive proof that this is happening which is a photo of two phones side by side going to the same location listing different prices despite how easy such proof would be to generate.

It's the same as the whole "Yelp deletes reviews if you don't buy ads" or "Facebook is listening to your microphone and serving you up ads". Proof is easy to generate and yet it never appears, only endlessly more anecdotes and speculation.

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2018/apr/13/uber-l...

Reach out to any news organization than. They love selling uber is evil and this would be breaking news for them.

I don’t believe you because I hardly believe anything i read in comment sections. People are normally under informed or being malicious.

I did a Google search and Forbes and other sites goes into this matter. I could say the same thing about you and that you deny it because you somehow benefits from it.

But in any case I still use it because I find it useful regardless of this custom pricing

Is it possible that since multiple users requested a ride with the same source and destination that it triggered "surge" pricing?
It could but it was the other way around though. He requested after me so we used his ride instead. I guess the demand went down after I requested it? who knows