Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by LudwigNagasena 1636 days ago
That looks awful as a concept. I hope it doesn’t get any traction.
6 comments

Some of these are pretty pretentious and it means one company can claim the 2ld for their industry, eg https://story.new and https://repo.new
That's no different from the current world. Three different apps claim to just be "Messenger" on my phone. Books.com goes to only one seller.
I agree, writing more about my reasoning last year at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27162905. It gets you an only slightly shorter URL, while significantly diluting trust.
Why? From my point of view it's no different from any other 'pretty' domain name.
A TLD shouldn't have semantic meaning already covered by protocol operations.
What do I put in my URL bar to make it POST?
A lot of these TLDs just put anything up to justify their reasoning for registering the domain. They don't believe that is how the domain will be (ab)used, but they have to publicly provide some nonsense reason for its existence.

I looked up the application for .one gTLD today. I own a subdomain and I wanted to know the original reasoning behind it. It is (now) owned by one.com and they basically told ICANN "we are going to do ONE stuff with it. Like stuff to do with ONE. And we have customers. And like, er, Beanie Babies?" And ICANN said "That sounds excellent, here's the domain, please continue with your master plan."

For the most part ICANN is doing them a solid. If your name lacks any real purpose, you are going to be on the hook paying for the registry to exist with nowhere near enough customers to justify it existence. So, get a purpose or expect to throw away your money.

Successful non-CC TLDs are rare. There are a few, but they have a clear purpose. For example Russia's .рф is er... for Russian stuff. In Russian. But what is .horse really for? Not very much besides hooking me up with "My Lovely Horse" http://my.lovely.horse/ any time I want to listen to it again.

That's awesome. As soon as I heard it I thought "That sounds like The Divine Comedy" and I looked it up, and there it was. Fantastic. Can highly recommend the rest of The Divine Comedy's oeuvre too.
Yes. I can likewise recommend the British TV comedy that clip is from, "Father Ted".
I wonder if it feels more natural for different cultures or language structures, to me doing something like sheets.new isn't the order I output in - something like "/new sheets" (and without the .) feels normal, natural, but perhaps because of my own personal experience and exposures.
In fairness, that's because domains are for some reason written backwards from the rest of the URL anyways. By rights, that URL should be https://new.sheets/ just as this discussion should be https://com.ycombinator.news/item?id=29769511
It already has traction. sheets.new is a very common shortcut.