Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by shadilay 1809 days ago
Having a price even if ridiculous allows researches to write papers like "What brand has the most affordable repairs".
2 comments

Dear god that's a stretch of the word "researcher" if ever I've seen one. Yes, that article would take some "research" (as in, finding stuff) but nope, the person writing it wouldn't be a "researcher" for it. They'd be a journalist. At 9to5 or such probably.
I’m not sure it is. What verb does someone do when they collect and collate data about products at consumer reports, tom’s hardware, or even the low bar of linus tech tips?

I’d say while the primary role may be journalist at most of these types of orgs, there is definitely a role for people who focus on the research side of things, and if you’re actively running experiments and benchmarks, you are definitely moving out of the realm of simple observation. I certainly would like to benefit from the data of which phone is cheapest to repair. iFixit already does the research to grade repairability of devices.

What you describe sounds like the role of an analyst e.g. like the famous Patrick Moorhead
I think the role of an analyst is to draw conclusions from an existing dataset whereas research is the act of creating a new dataset.
also even if the price is really expensive, I would pay it if it meant recovering my lost data on a phone.
Indeed, though effective regulations requiring phone manufacturers and app developers to stop trying to lock your data into their device or software wouldn't be a bad thing either. The ability to back up your own data on your own terms would be a good start. Some recent legal changes, such as the GDPR in Europe, have attempted to guarantee this access when services have your data. But apparently having your own device lock you in is still OK for some reason.