Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by tyingq 1889 days ago
Somewhat questions the value of these symbols versus text. Not disparaging the app, I'd need one to tell what they meant too.
1 comments

Text requires translation into thousands of languages.
As do cryptic and unreadable symbols.
Not on every piece of clothing you sell.
The exact opposite is true. These symbols require (but do not have) translation on every piece of clothing, because almost no-one understands what they mean, and it's not currently possible to type them in to Google to identify their meaning.

On the other hand, if the text was just in a language that I did not speak, I can either type this into a translation app myself, or use the automatic translation camera on my phone to identify them.

And sure, I can apparently now do that for those washing symbols too, which is nice... but why is that information being conveyed in a "language" that almost no-one speaks? I'd be just as confused if every item of clothing I purchased had washing instructions in Lojban.

I fully understand why an attempt at standardised symbols was made, being able to communicate that information more compactly would be useful, but it very clearly failed. They're not intuitive enough to learn without third-party resources, and a very very tiny fraction of the population is willing to put in the effort to do so. Just use text.

Everyone who washes clothes more than once a month will learn the meaning of this symbols rather quickly.

They are like traffic lights.

Current state, I would have to figure out what to type into google to see what some symbol like ⧇ or △ means in laundry terms. Either better symbols I don't have to google, or text in a language that I don't speak...but can figure out. The ones with temperatures don't even have a degree mark.
It's strange that on a site like Hacker News people are so averse to learning new things. We seem to have no problem learning other kinds of symbol languages. These are standard symbols - you can search Google for "laundry symbols" to find a key
It's not just the HN crowd. My non techie spouse isn't a fan either. It's also a meme. https://i.pinimg.com/474x/63/47/c3/6347c34b1ac9f34e3a27eb36d...
The audience for the symbols are people who do laundry for a living.

Symbols that you never use aren't very useful when all you really need to know is "do not dry", "do not bleach", "wash with like colors". It's really not that big of a deal to put a tag written in English and Spanish to the US, or in French to France, etc.

HN folks complain all day that their computers and phones changed since the 90s.
I would agree. The issue isn't that they are symbols, it is that the symbols are really hard to understand, other than hand wash where a hand is in a bucket of water the rest have little connection with the outside world.
No, it doesn't. Just type it into google. And each user only needs to do that once.