Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by scotty79 2101 days ago
I hope they'll be able to continue providing Messenger. It's a successor of skype for me
2 comments

I'm glad it works for you. I hate it so much I'm telling everyone not to contact me there. It's integrated too deeply with Facebook. I actually succeeded to get people I talk to the most contact me on Signal instead, and they quite like it. (Signal now supports calls from the desktop client)
I wouldn't say it particularly works for me in any specific way. It's just that everybody that was on skype years ago is now on messenger plus some new people. Deep facebook integration is cause of this so I can't be mad at it.
Telegram is much better than Messenger. Why don't you use it? Plus there are ton's of more features. Like so many, its hard to keep up.

It's ad free and open source.

No end to end encryption is deal breaker for most.
He is switching from messenger. It's not exactly leading the way in privacy.

Signal is not alternative to Messenger. Signal is an alternative to whatsapp.

I doubt that is true and anyway Telegram does have end to end encryption.
It does but not by default and it only works between two specific devices.
Which is why I recommended it as an alternative to Messenger.
Which means you get better usability by default and E2E when you need it.
Telegram still uses MTProto which was criticized for making quite a few odd choices.

It’s odd that people would recommend it over say Signal.

I'd say Telegram is probably the "nicest" app I've used for messaging. WhatsApp and Messenger are Ok. Signal, whilst being idealistically the best, is spartan, kinda ugly, and lacks many features that make messaging "fun".
Signal is openly hostile to alternative clients, making it hardly better than other corporations' offerings.
Alternative client without being to independently verify their correctness do not fit the trust model of Signal or any of the chat systems.
Signal cannot be even compared to Telegram. they are different. Telegram is Discord+Messenger, but on steroids.
> Telegram is much better than Messenger. Why don't you use it?

Because nobody that I want to talk to has it.

The answer to this question is always "network effects". No-one that I know uses Telegram.
Telegram has been picking up steam in my wide network. It's been surprising to me how easy it was, as an early adopter, to convince people to use it. It doesn't work with everyone; WhatsApp dominates around here. But in the tens of people that I care to communicate with have happily switched to Telegram for much of their chatting.
Why don't you be the first one?

https://telegram.org

Once you start using it, you will never go back. It's awesome compared to Skype and messenger.

Yes, you will go back, because using a messenger alone is kind of pointless.
> Why don't you use it?

Because you need to convince all your friends to use it...