Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by sroussey 2121 days ago
How would apple monetize this search engine?

I don’t completely trust Apple with doing ads as they already do plenty of self-dealing with their own ad system.

If anything, they should jedison their ad product altogether.

2 comments

For example, in iOS 14 they added a Tracking permission and a slider in Settings > Privacy > Tracking. Except to have them not track you requires a separate setting in Settings > Privacy > Apple Advertising > Personalization.
Presumably the same way they monetize Siri.
Siri is an exclusive feature of iPhones, that's how it's "monetized". This is unlike GA which is available on iOS [0]. So unless this search engine is exclusive to iPhone users as a way of "keeping their privacy intact", I don't see how they can justify running a free search engine for everyone.

[0] https://apps.apple.com/ca/app/google-assistant/id1220976145

Yeah, I think if Apple launches their own search engine, it will take the form of a change that results in Apple handling more searches from Apple devices themselves.

Kind of like Apple Maps, which "competes" with Google Maps but only on Apple devices. You can't just point any web browser at an Apple Maps website the way you can with Google Maps. I doubt that Apple would launch a search engine that you can just browse to from anywhere like Google or Bing.

That’s good enough for basics then, and nothing for Google to worry about.

Or a great way to make it so no one competes with their partner google — by offering a totally free (and ad-free) search that’s good enough for many use cases but not great.