Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by ownedthx 2214 days ago
JamKazam founder here. Happy to come across a user!

We see that too: 25ms one-way latency is the max to stay in sync, and that includes both internet + audio device encode/decode, which gets eaten up quite fast!

We are looking at providing an optional premium networking service to offer a faster connection as an alternative to the open internet. Nothing too expensive, like $10/month is the goal. Hope that gets you and your friends under that magic threshold when it's available, if you try it out.

4 comments

I've been experimenting with it too, with my funk band. Very quickly we realized that any latency was too high for us to have a hope of getting in the pocket, but it worked quite well for sloppier rock jams.

Since you're here, I'll ping you some feedback:

- The UX is, charitably, idiosyncratic. We all found it hellaciously difficult to get started, find each other, start a session that didn't have strangers popping into it, manage audio (more on that below). The UI is honestly just super crazy insanely weird.

- The audio handling is... counterintuitive too. I expect to be able to control my "monitor" mix, and have one person control the master mix. But that just isn't working. Instead of one channel strip per source, we just each see a single fader for each participant (even though each person has vocal mic and instrument mic) and it seems to affect everyone globally.

- Everyone slows down over the course of the song. We're all listening to each other, so the latency builds, and we all end up dragging horribly. Only solution we found was to have the drummer play to a click which is miserable in our genre and generally not fun outside of a studio session (which is "work" anyway).

I _really_ hope you're able to use some of the newfound interest you've got to inject some new life into the service. The core is so promising. Notwithstanding that feedback, I'd pay $10/mo for a non-social private version where I can host my own server, since all my bandmates are within a mile of me.

I think JamKazam is helping some of my friends maintain what little is left of their sanity in the current climate, so thank you for that!

Unfortunately I might not be in many sessions for a while as I replaced my last Windows machine with Linux this weekend, which I don't think you support yet; although I will have a go at getting it working in WINE :)

Hi! This was already asked before, but probably my voice would be heard: do Jamkazam team support Linux? Currently we're using Jamulus for practicing, but I would like to compare it with Jamkazam. Unfortunately, some of our members are *nix guys.

Do you plan to work on Linux support? Thanks!

Hi, I clicked on the learn more link for the jamblaster and it’s a dead link?
wince

We need to take that section/link down.

We did do a KickStarter for the JamBlaster, made ~200 and shipped them.

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/1091884999/jamblaster-t...

But we are not in a position to be focusing on custom hardware.

... a dedicated device is half the puzzle. That, and a low-latency network connection to your peers. You have those two and you can get a reliable experience.

For people that are interested in putting something like this together, Bela might be a good starting point.

https://bela.io