Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by colordrops 2270 days ago
Are only biological systems capable of experiencing qualia? What is to say that a silicon computer can't also have subjective experiences?
3 comments

I do sometimes entertain the idea of panpsychism (like perhaps a rock is conscious), and consciousness may not be substrate dependent, but I can be certain, by at least my own anecdata, that neurons give rise to qualia.

The jury is still out on this, but a big-world network with some quantum computation could be enough. The 'hard problem of consciousness' is that we can't really know by observing a system whether it is conscious or not, or rather a sort of 'zombie' that has all the features resembling a conscious being without qualia.

Arguably, computers seems to suffer when there are be computations : they becomes hot and start to breathe a lot. That's a little irrational be I used to feel a little bad when I saw my old computer "suffering" when I was younger.
Seems unlikely that's suffering, any more than petrol suffers.

Animals (like us) suffer as part of our evolved aversion response. We have an in-built capacity for preference. Current-day computers lack this.

Just because you are hot and breath a lot it doesn't mean you are suffering, you are just working more. You start to suffer when you work over your limits, like when you overclock a computer too much and starts to glitch because some parts of it cannot handle it.
That's the big question that science so far has no clue about.