Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by suddenseizure 2582 days ago
I've been following this field with great interest since my wife was diagnosed with brain cancer.

It seems many types of cancer can evolve resistance to treatment with a single type of immunotherapy. Similar to how HIV quickly evolved resistance to treatment by one ARV (antiretroviral).

But HIV can be kept in check by a cocktail of 3 ARVs simultaneously. And there's some recent research from Mass General where they managed to eradicate brain tumors in mice using 3 different immunotherapies simultaneously: https://advances.massgeneral.org/neuro/journal.aspx?id=1263

> Dr. Curry's group describes "a likely oversimplified, but reasonable" summary of the mechanism of the triple therapy: GVAX expands the number and diversity of activated tumor-specific T cells and increases the number of intratumor CD8+ T cells, while PD-1 inhibition further invigorates the effects of those mobilized cells. Meanwhile, agonist anti-OX40 continues to skew systemic and tumor microenvironments toward Th1 immunity, suppress regulatory T cells and prevent T cell exhaustion.

Hopefully this is a way forward for treating humans too!

4 comments

Re: resistance - it's not that the tumor is resistant to the immunotherapy, it's that the tumor is resistant to the immune system, and the therapy provided doesn't do the right thing to break down the resistance barrier. There are literally dozens of unique ways a tumor can suppress the immune system. So the challenge for each patient is finding which ones the tumor is using .

There are cases of adaptive resistance to immune-based therapies. These are less common, although they do arise. However, it is still the same kind of game - tumors use the same tricks to hide from an immune response ignited by an immunotherapy as they do from an immune response without immunotherapy.

Looking through your post history, it seems you wife is doing much better than my dad did with his brain cancer. I assume then that it isn't glioblastoma. That shit is nasty.

Anyway, I hope things continue to remain reasonably in check for her. Cancer is a terrible thing.

Yes, we are relatively lucky that it's a low grade glioma. Sorry to hear about your dad, GBM is a monster.

The oncologist told us life expectancy is around 15 years which, while ~10x better than GBM, is a pretty disappointing thing to hear when you're in your early thirties. But that number comes from looking back at people diagnosed in recent decades, so we're really hoping that new treatments will change the equation going forward.

Do you follow the standard of treatment given by the doctor? What about diet modifications (ketosis) or other supplements (metformin, etc)?
>> It seems many types of cancer can evolve resistance to treatment with a single type of immunotherapy

This is true.

Interestingly, they're now starting to use Game Theory to beat cancer [1].

[1] http://fortune.com/2018/08/10/beating-cancer-game-theory/

Yes, it is promising. I am sorry to hear about your wife. Hopeful it gets fast tracked to clinical trials.