Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by turtlesdown 2619 days ago
First, you originally claimed meat as a factor (apparently still after an edit). Second, a vegetarian can eat dairy products. Finally, the only working link above is pretty much worthless (122 participants who were asked questions, measured, and checked again in 3 years) as it does not capture final adult height.

>Also, "properly nourished" is a weasel phrase here.

For sure, just like debating about meat consumption and pivoting to just dairy consumption as proof...

1 comments

You need to remove the semi-colons from the link above. Three different studies showing that milk consumption results in taller children.

As to your second point--the issue under debate here is not meat consumption, but rather the CO2 emissions of animal agriculture. So we're talking about telling Bangladeshis to be vegans, not merely vegetarians.

https://data-wrapper.s3.amazonaws.com/vpwr6/3/index.html https://earthscience.stackexchange.com/a/10177

Huh, these numbers really disagree in a couple places.

Nevertheless it seems like the most important way to minimize CO2 is to focus on grains, and that milk, eggs, poultry, pork, and fish aren't all that bad compared to the average vegetable.

And milk's easy to budget for, two cups a day is only 10% of a kid's calories.