Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by pjmlp 2819 days ago
Given that Unity uses different conventions for property names and magical function names with reflection for events, that is a dialect to me, as it is not how C# is used by regular developers.

Actually there are occasional questions on C# forums caused by people learning C# via Unity and then facing issues when using pure .NET.

Then there is the new HPC# for the new ECS and Job systems, which subsets C#.

As for Mono being already in 1.0, OS X only version, I am unsure about it, but the old blog was taken down. So I take your word for it.

1 comments

That's just coding style, which by itself is not a new dialect. Yes a bunch of APIs in Unity use different naming conventions from the rest of .NET world, but the language is the same.

The new HPC#/Burst indeed are subsets of C#, but that's a very recent development, and completely unrelated to "Unity had to make their own C# dialect to avoid Novell/Xamarin licensing issues".

> As for Mono being already in 1.0, OS X only version, I am unsure about it, but the old blog was taken down

I have worked at Unity since 2006. Yes Unity was Mac only at that point, but it still used Mono there.

My remark had to do more with being stuck in a v3.5 world, thus making Unity devs live in an universe quite different than what everyone else is using in terms of APIs and language features, on top of Unity specific behaviors like those magical methods called by the component framework.