Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dijit 2897 days ago
You can't hijack a train and take hostages to some other country; This was endemic in the 80s.

You also can't hijack a train and drive it into a building.

2 comments

You can divert it remotely by dispatch if the route is fully signalled. Trains cannot travel except what rails direct them to.
But is this still true for airplanes, given the switch to hardened cockpit doors?
It is still true; Holding a train full of passengers hostage is foolish because there's no possibility that a train driver could disengage the rails.

Holding a plane full of passengers hostage is less foolish because the pilots/flight attendants can be bribed and bartered- it's not a technical impossibility to do certain actions, so there is more of an incentive.

Then you get Germanwings incidents
Which can't happen on trains and buses?
Buses, maybe. Trains: Nope. Doors are locked from the inside, usually aren't accessible while moving and even someone would get inside, well, you can't get off the tracks. You'll get a red signal and a forced braking shortly afterwards. It's really, REALLY hard (by design) to wreck something on purpose with a modern high speed train.
This is why electric trains are so nice: you can shut them off from the ground.
And in buses you can't really lock yourself out as a driver.
Which wasn't a hostage situation or a hijacking to get elsewhere, and it has nothing to do with the passenger security theater which is what this thread is about...