Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by woumn 2911 days ago
Out of curiosity, were these high CPU usages on pages with any sort of video playing (culprits for me were Twitch or any live stream)? I was also having these issues, and I want to use Firefox, but the performance in the past was just too difficult.
3 comments

I had the same issues and avoided FF 57+ because of it. I just tried FF 61 and my results were mixed. Twitch and Youtube still made my CPU temps spike a little bit. It seems worse than Chrome but better than FF 57.

Google Maps, unfortunately, still made my CPU temp spike 30C+ as soon as I opened it. I use Maps a lot, so this is still a deal breaker for me.

Glad it's not just me. All of those really seem to stress Firefox out on my iMac. Chrome is far more efficient with something like Twitch.

Interesting thing I've noticed: If you don't use chat much and just want the video, try using Twitch's "pop-out" player that opens in its own window- for me this uses far less CPU (even in Chrome)

Chrome's "switch to fullscreen" transition on twitch for me is super laggy though, and I haven't been able to solve that one (Firefox switches to fullscreen smoothly).

Yea, most of my browser time spent during free time is strictly on Twitch/Youtube/Netflix. Until these see improvements, then I won't make the switch.
I only use firefox (for privacy reasons). But the macbook-burning-a-hole-in-my-pants behaviour that firefox creates on these sites has led me to using mpv with youtube-dl to watch most of youtube and all of twitch. If you have both installed you can just do a 'mpv https://www.twitch.tv/username' and it will work quite nicely. You might need to set up mpv to get the best quality, I think putting 'ytdl-format=bestvideo+bestaudio/best' in ~/.config/mpv/mpv.conf is sufficient. HTH.
I am also in this camp and want to say that twitch especially is just horrible for performance
Which is so surprising to me because it's using the HTML5 video player and toggling around with hardware acceleration does nothing to fix the issue. Perhaps it's the integrated chat + any of the add ones that Twitch has written for the videos?
I have noticed the pop-out player seems far more efficient, which leads me to think the chat and other things going on around the video might be the culprit
Unrelated, but what do people do on twitch? I worry about getting out of touch with my children.
In addition to FreeFulls comment, there are also talkshows/(video)podcasts. It's basically the main broadcasting platform for gamers and tech people.
Twitch is mostly people streaming video of themselves playing games, but there are also some programmers that stream as they write software.
Video has been a big culprit for me - in both FireFox and Chrome. I've actually taken to using Microsoft Edge when I plan to play video.
I use Opera as my personal browser and it handles video pretty well. It's running Chromium under the hood, and I don't think any major improvements have been made for video in Chromium or in any of the standards like HTML5 or flash. I see on par performance to stock Chrome.
I would lean towards "yes". Mostly problematic pages: YouTube and Twilio dashboard.