Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by wildbunny 3253 days ago
Bitcoin hasn't solved the scaling problem. All these BIPs are just short term fixes which don't address the core problem. I opened a discussion thread on bitcointalk hoping to catch the attention of the core developers, but it seems they don't read that forum anymore.

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=2036368.0

3 comments

I'm tired of Bitcoin's useless drama.
Useless to you and me, but quite a lot of fortunes are riding on this ponzi scheme.
> All these BIPs are just short term fixes which don't address > the core problem.

Wrong, SegWit (BIP 91 and 141) solves transaction malleability, which in itself will allow new layers (off-chain) to be built on top of the first layer (on-chain), which will allow orders of magnitude more throughput on number of payments per month.

Off-chain is, by definition, not Bitcoin. Bitcoin itself is still very limited in throughput, and will remain so until the block size is increased.
Wrong. When you sign a transaction off-chain, you're signing a real bitcoin transaction, which you choose (or your software) to not broadcast to the network for convenience reasons (as you will likely sign more transactions later).
Cores and the rest have already discussed about scaling to death. Such a radical change cannot be simply applied to Bitcoin. You just explained what IOTA is. If you must get their attention, go to slack/IRC or start a reddit thread and if it collects much attention, cores will likely to read.