Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by csl 3386 days ago
Note: The following is complete speculation and probably bullshit. Please correct me!

I can't find the actual paper for this one. But reading an older study [0], also about TMEM106B, it seems they had already established an association between three SNPs and frontotemporal lobar degeneration (FTLD) risk.

However, the surprise discovery back then seemed to be the large discrepancy between the controls and the subgroup FTLD-GNR (those with FTLD and GNR mutations) for TT rs6966915 and CC rs1990622. See table 2 in [0], and look at the odds ratios. They are remarkably low for TT/CC, which invites further study that may lead to understand how to protect against FTLD (by understanding possible protective mechanisms, even therapies and so on).

As for listing out those odds ratios for your 23andMe genome, you can do it with arv [1]. For table 1 in the study (unless you know you have GNR mutations):

  import arv
  
  genome = arv.load("genome.txt")
  
  rsid = "rs6966915"
  gt = genome.get_snp(rsid).genotype # plus orientation
  print("%s %s" % (rsid, arv.unphased_match(gt, {
      "CC": "CC - OR 0.94",
      "CT": "CT - OR 1.04",
      "TT": "TT - OR 0.74"})))
  
  rsid = "rs1990622"
  gt = ~genome.get_snp(rsid).genotype # minus orientation
  print("%s %s" % (rsid, arv.unphased_match(gt, {
      "TT": "TT - OR 0.93",
      "CT": "CT - OR 1.04",
      "CC": "CC - OR 0.74"})))
Again, did I say that I'm a complete noob? Be very careful drawing conclusions from the program (or believing I know what I'm talking about --- I don't!)

[0]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3034409/

[1]: https://github.com/cslarsen/arv

2 comments

I wonder whether this variant is similar to APOE E4 allele—which significantly increases one's risk of Alzheimer's—in that its affect can be minimized by lifestyle changes.

In men, APOE E4's disadvantages can be almost completely eliminated (compared to APOE E3) by regularly exercising and completely abstaining from alcohol.

I haven't seen many research papers that claim abstaining from alcohol helps reduce ALZ risk in E4 carriers. Care to share?
As I understand this only works for E3/E4 variants. Not homozygous E4/E4.
Welp, looks legit to me.

Someone who knows what they're talking about tell us noobs any major gotchas with this sort of approach, please :)