| > secret If your culture is one of secrecy (Google's generally is not), then you need process to effect coordination, since nothing else can. Fortunately, good (IMHO) software companies are internally open, so there's no secrecy forcing them into heavyweight process. Process is one of the many costs of secrecy. > formalized process The problem with formalized anything is that it involves writing down rules. When you write down rules, you have to distill complex and subtle human interactions into essentially an algorithm for people to follow. The loss of nuance, while creating clarity, introduces inefficiency, since it forces everyone to follow the same steps even when these steps are inappropriate. You can't write down exceptions for all the inappropriate cases (but you can for some of them). If you tried to allow for a large number of exceptions, the resulting algorithm would be too complex to follow or it would be vague enough to allow anyone to skirt the rules. I prefer to avoid formal rulesets for human processes. In my experience, the efficiency loss arising from formal rulemaking has outweighed the gain in clarity. Maybe others have different experiences, but in mine, the higher the quality of developer you have in an organization, the fewer formal rules you need. Applying lots of formal rules to good developers just makes them unhappy. |
Internally open does not mean that everyone can always see everything though.
>Applying lots of formal rules to good developers just makes them unhappy.
I'm not sure I agree with this. I'm a developer, and I'm happier when there are formal rules about human code review, code style, automated testing, and minimal test coverage.
I'm happy about those things because they are a small inconvenience (if one at all) that save me time and effort down the line, and insulate me from lazyness, and mistakes on the part of developers (myself included!).
I see design documents as an extension of this. My pay in is that I occasionally need to write a document outlining my thought process w.r.t. a new (large-ish) feature I'm implementing. In exchange for this, I know that I will not waste my time reinventing things and, more importantly, when other people intend to make changes that will potentially negatively impact me, I will be able to provide feedback before those changes go live.