Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by fdsfsaa 3462 days ago
> Internally open does not mean that everyone can always see everything though.

If secrecy is rare in an organization, secrecy-induced problems in that organization are also rare.

> I'm not sure I agree with this. I'm a developer, and I'm happier when there are formal rules about human code review, code style, automated testing, and minimal test coverage.

It takes all kinds, I guess. Personally, nothing galls me more than having to follow a rigid set of rules when I know the original motivation for these rules doesn't apply to my situation. I'd make a terrible soldier.

I understand your social contract argument, but IME, the benefit to me of other people writing design documents isn't big enough to justify my having to do it. I find that subscribing to actual code reviews targeting directories that interest me gives me enough ability to see and affect (and unfortunately, sometimes block or delay) changes before they go live.