Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by nutschig 3538 days ago
Silicon is not the best transistor material ever. For example, gallium arsenide can run at a switching frequency of 250 GHz thanks to faster electron velocity and higher electron mobility. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gallium_arsenide#GaAs_advantag...
4 comments

You can create some pretty high frequency transistors (BJTs) with Indium Phosphide (InP) (ft > 600GHz, fmax > 1THz). See page 33 of:

http://www.ece.ucsb.edu/Faculty/rodwell/publications_and_pre...

...for examples of some 600 GHz circuits, and:

http://www.semiconductor-today.com/news_items/2014/OCT/NORTH...

...for a >1THz circuit using InP HEMTs.

Wow that's crazy.

I wonder how you even test a 1THz amplifier. Also what kind of natural noise might exist in those bands

> I wonder how you even test a 1THz amplifier.

The usual schtick is to measure the S-parameters a slower speeds and extrapolate out to the cutoff. (see chart 21 from the link above: http://www.ece.ucsb.edu/Faculty/rodwell/publications_and_pre...)

For the digital people, building a ring oscillator with N stages will cause the output to divide by N, and just make sure that f/N is in the range of your oscilloscope.

To actually measure things up in the THz range directly, there are more exotic methods: Superconducting bolometer is one that I've been involved with. But those are a PITA for a bunch of reasons.

>I wonder how you even test a 1THz amplifier.

Most likely using a mixer or some other non-linearity to down convert into the frequency range of your spectrum analyzer.

And how do you get the 1THz signal in the 1st place? Maybe upconvert as well?
Does 'Heisenberg' or some other theory limit the top frequency, if so, what's the limit?
I, for one, have a Germanium transistor in my 1964 Accutron Bulova watch. So there!

http://www.decadecounter.com/accutron/history.htm

Old joke: It's not that Germanium has a bad bandgap, it's just that room temperature is wrong.

[As it turns out, having a decent native oxide is also a winner.)

> thanks to faster electron velocity and higher electron mobility.

How does this effect energy transfer? This is the metric I assume most people care about as it is typically much faster than an electron can move.

"Best" is a funny word, because it means different things to people who care about different things. Silicon can be built with better gates / insulators than gallium arsenide, so if that's what you care about, silicon is better.