Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by aavotins 3672 days ago
It's BGA, so it's soldered onto the motherboard/logic board. Non user upgradeable, and if the SSD dies, you're in for a costly repair. Another step in the direction of (very) disposable hardware with little to no service options.
3 comments

This isn't necessarily the case. The article explicitly talks about physical standards for putting them on M.2 cards, and how some are already shipping on M.2 and PCI-E form factors.
Surely someone can solder it onto an USB stick, SATA interface, etc. with the added circuitry of supporting those interfaces.
Does the other packages give you this ability? The other fine pitch parts are also very difficult to change over.
This is a chip that gets soldered directly on the board. While it is possible to solder this specific chip to a detachable interface that can be removed, I highly doubt anyone will ever do it.

This form factor has a huge advantage for OEMs - they can just slap on a single chip that has everything built in - controller, memory management and the actual storage. Less parts = less convoluted assembly process and that is cheaper. While theoretically you can put a BGA fully integrated SSD SOC like this on a PCI-E card or M2 etc., it kinda beats the purpose.

Personally, I think BGA parts are great. They are small and quite robust mechanically an highly integrated (as you have said).

I did my early engineering years with DIP parts, the days of when you could just desolder the memory device and place with a higher density device are long gone.

SATA, PCIe, and M.2 drives are trivial to replace.