Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Tiktaalik 3696 days ago
Nice. Maybe with this I can convince my friends to move over to WhatsApp from Google Hangouts. The lack of desktop app support for Hangouts has been driving me nuts.
5 comments

You could just open hangouts.google.com in a browser window, why do you need a native app?

Also, Hangouts would not need phone tethering

It's incredibly frustrating to find the one tab/window you have open to hangouts when you have dozens of windows/tabs open.
Hangouts does have a Chrome app (not extension, but app). Which runs in a pop-up mode and gives a user interface similar to android.

Also, it starts up with your operating system with a floating icon which stays at top of the windows if you want, and provides notifications. Your friends can use that if they want to stick to hangouts.

[Hangouts Chrome App](https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/google-hangouts/nc...)

WhatsApp has (proper) end-to-end encryption which is IMO a big win over Hangouts.
Why do you need desktop app support for Hangouts? You can install the extension.
Because I can't cmd-tab to it. Because it brings every Chrome window to front if I just want to read a message. Because it floats on top of Chrome whenever it's open. Because I can't easily move it between monitors, or to a different part of the screen. It's also really rubbish at uploading files. Why can't I drag and drop? And how about search? You're Google ffs. Why do I have to go to Gmail to search Hangouts, instead of allowing search in, oh I don't know, how about in Hangouts?

Some of these may have changed since I abandoned Hangouts last year for Telegram, which still has the best desktop experience.

I don't use Hangouts, but I thought Google hangouts now has a desktop app variant that solves the problems you mentioned.
> Because it brings every Chrome window to front if I just want to read a message

Are you using a Mac by any chance?

Yes, hence cmd-tab.
Ok, then that is the reason for the issues you see but you probably already knew.

Edit: removed lots of unnecessary text : )

It's only the reason for it inasmuch as Hangouts is implemented in a way that behaves like this on Mac. It's not as if it's an inherent property of the OS.
use Hangouts as a desktop app... https://github.com/jiahaog/nativefier