Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by barrkel 3719 days ago
All buildings in cities have a social component; the whole reason you're in a city rather than in a campus or remote plot of land is because there are other people, and relations with these other people are important. If buildings turn into towers of exclusivity, thumbing their nose at outsiders walking by, it harms the connection to other people. It becomes part of the character of the city and ulmitately makes the city worse off. And that in turn harms the people who own the building; not only do they devalue the building by harming the city, but they make it harder to hire people since fewer people want to live in a city like that.
1 comments

Look, if you want trees on your building then put them there. It shouldn't matter whether it makes anyone else jealous. Let them buy their own trees.
Companies are made out of people who interact with other people. Why would people want to work for a company that acts like a dick?

Not only is it self harm, but it also pollutes the public space, and the public has a say in that too. We don't yet live in an autocracy.

I can see we're probably not going to come to any resolution. I think you believe more strongly in absolute property rights, while I believe that if you want absolute property rights, you should relocate outside a city where you don't have neighbours. Neighbours make all the difference. They have to suffer your outward appearances. If you're going to put up a hostile face, they're going to be hostile right back, and there are more of them than there are of you.

Trees pollute the public space? If mixing neighbors and trees causes problems, then the problem is with the neighbors, not the trees. Trees are awesome. Assuming sustainable low-pollen species are chosen, why not cover every building in green?
Trees don't pollute the public space; a view of inaccessible trees pollutes the public viewscape.
The same argument can be made against anything. I might have a car you can see. But you can't access it. Does this pollute the public viewscape? You might have windows or balconies that I can see, but I can't access them. Does this pollute the public viewscape?