It gives an advantage to attorneys that can afford it. The vast majority of cases that see trial probably don't have a lot of money for the defense to spend on such things, while the prosecution has access to the DA's site license or whatever.
It's hard to believe this wouldn't end up mostly used by prosecutors.
Like I said though, with courtrooms being adversarial one side is incentivized to use any useful tool against the other. If the defense can't afford it and therefore doesn't use it, it becomes less likely the prosecution will use it then too. Maybe to counteract this I have to subsidize the cost of those using it for defense.
It is far to early to say for certain, but in order to generate better juror recommendations data is needed, I want as many people using it as possible to get data.
If the defense can't afford it and therefore doesn't use it, it becomes less likely the prosecution will use it then too.
That's exceptionally unlikely, I think. The prosecution's job is to win, whatever the cost--that appears to be the current mode of operation in the US, anyways.
Even so, I do have some benefit to having defense attorneys use it. I'll get more data on jurors.
Having people pay what they will or can isn't a new idea. If the defense can't pay an individual license may be cheap, while an office license could be exorbitant if the DA will pay through the nose.
The main point of the last post is that I gain nothing if they don't use it, but if anyone is paying for it I still gain from other free users.
As I mentioned the I think system is suboptimal, I think this can improve it though. I'm not a jerk who would screw the Justice system for a buck, I really do think this can improve things. I don't think the possibility that it might hurt is reason enough not to try.
This. Kind of what I said in the main post. It seems crappy that you're giving someone an advantage, but it would be available to both sides. The justice system is structured this way because they believe attorneys will act in their self interest only and by letting them both do so it will be fair. I'm just allowing them both to have better tools while they do it.
It's hard to believe this wouldn't end up mostly used by prosecutors.