Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Velox 3894 days ago
That's absolutely not the case. My issue is that AgileBits need to push the new format over the old one. The old one is still the default. Most users, my self included, have no idea that the old format is insecure, or that a new format exists.

The article has very limited technical details to avoid confusing people who don't know what they are doing, but the reality is that if they are reading my blog, or are reading HN then they have the technical details to understand something much more complex than what I wrote.

I clearly state at the bottom of the article that the software still keeps your passwords secure and that I will continue to use 1Password. AgileBits still have my full support, I just want them to inform the users the downsides of using agile keychain, and to use OPVault by default.

1 comments

The old format is not 'Default' but Dropbox Sync users. I'm using iCloud Sync and I'm not affect by these problem.

My point being why you are talking about these issues in YCNews but their forum. Most of us just read 140 characters but an article, This is how information transfer today. I'm not finding excuses for AgileBits. The problem you mention need to be fix. But it's important where you talk about it. If there's a news said your product 'Leaking your data' in YCNews, and everybody will know that '1Password is leaking data', but 'The author of this article is still using 1Password'.

> My point being why you are talking about these issues in YCNews but their forum.

This is the flip side of "software as a consumer product" that sells for $60. If it's open source, the author could have discussed it on the bugtracker, posted to the mailing list / forum, or even just recompiled to use the old format by default, and you would have been justified in asking them to do so.

A commercial product that sells for $60? That's like a toaster oven or something. If my toaster oven is malfunctioning, I'm not going to go complain on their forum, I'm going to air my grievances in public and demand a new toaster (in this case, an updated version of 1Password).