| Let me first state why I disagree with you, and then why I don't think you should be downvoted.
(at the time I'm writing this, parent's post is light grey.) Time and time again, studies demonstrate that we are all a little bit racist.
Another commenter pointed out that the Implicit Association Test is a nice introduction to this research.
You can take a test here: https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit/takeatest.html Unconscious discrimination is a serious source of hardship for minorities and it's important to be aware
of our bias. This is what the author of the article is getting at, and he is correct in the central point. However, we live in a culture where racists are the scum of the earth, fired from their jobs, ostracized,
hated universally. You can even be fired from your job if you defend someone that's a racist [1] Given how hated racism is in our culture right now, debate about racial issues is skewed in three ways. First, we might not take the side of the privileged in an issue because we fear we are being unconsciously racist. Second, we might not take the side of the privileged in an issue because we fear we might be called a racist, and,
if not immediately fired from ours jobs, at least shunned. Finally, we might not take the side of the privileged in an issue, because even if taking their side would be technically correct, the privileged already have enough privilege, so to say, and by speaking out in favor of them we might be weakening the forces which are working hard to eliminate racism from society as much as possible. These biases can be just as unconscious. And they obscure the truth. Parent is also speaking out of fear. He has come to believe that acknowledging the existence of implicit racism,
is the same as always siding with the minority in every case. Even in cases where the minority is clearly in the wrong. If you value truth, this is an abomination. If you value truth enough, it's something to get extremely angry about.
By heavily downvoting parent's post, you are confirming these exact fears, while ignoring the true criticism hidden within. You are turning people away from the movement to eliminate racism, or at least making them less enthusiastic. And therefore you are doing more to slow the eradication of racism than posts like parent's ever would. Can we upvote parent for his bravery in speaking out against the bias our culture currently has?
And calmly and rationally debate his concerns? That would be infinitely more convincing than the downvote button. [1] http://www.gamerevolution.com/manifesto/turtle-rock-communit... |
(PaulHaugis does make some good points about lynchmods and bullying and it's weird that those posts get so heavily downvoted.)