Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by dev-da0 3974 days ago
Explanations aside, if in the slight chance it's workably better than ion thrusters for certain applications, that's great. If it turns out to be snake oil or a hoax, that would not be a huge surprise either.
2 comments

There are independent replications, which IMO mostly rule out hoaxes -- or at least greatly reduce the likelihood to below other explanations. It's tough to create an independently reproducible hoax.

Right now my guess is either measurement artifact or some form of obscure but conventional effect like EM interaction with the surround environment. That's most likely.

If those can be ruled out, then we're in new physics territory.

An ISP of infinity would be quite a lot better than ion thrusters, yes, and that's what they're suggesting.
It's not an ISP of infinity.

You're forgetting mass-energy equivalence. <x> energy / <y> thrust is a specific impulse, once you work in the factor of c^2 (that being the minimum amount of mass you need to burn to get the energy to produce the thrust.)

In this case, for instance, they are saying they think it produced 20 uN with an input of 700w. That works out to an effective specific impulse of 2.5x10^9m/s as an upper limit (yes, this is tachyonic. One of the problems with this drive is that it throws conservation of energy and momentum out the window...), assuming we could convert mass to energy directly. (If you're using D-T fusion, it's a specific impulse of ~9.7x10^6m/s instead as an upper limit, assuming 339.72 TJ/kg. Other reactions are lower.)

If you're assuming solar panels or some other external power source, then the only real difference between this and a laser is that this produces a constant factor more thrust per energy input. Sure, it's reactionless - but, effectively, so is a neutrino source, for instance. All that means is that you don't need to be as careful as to which direction you burn in.

Ion thrusters still require expendable fuel as well as an electrical power supply, if you can cut out the need for expendable fuel that would mean allot for space travel especially to the outer solar system and beyond.