Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by gandalfu 3984 days ago
From the press release: http://www.media.chrysler.com/newsrelease.do?id=16849&mid=1

"No defect has been found. FCA US is conducting this campaign out of an abundance of caution."

What the hell?

4 comments

Defect appears to have a particular meaning in relation to vehicle safety. I'm just basing that on the way it is used here:

http://www-odi.nhtsa.dot.gov/recalls/recallprocess.cfm

I guess it isn't that big a stretch to use such defensive language, there are a lot of things that can be tampered with on a vehicle that arise out of engineering trade offs.

I don't mean to dismiss the problem at hand, but it is only an issue if someone makes an effort to tamper with a vehicle, which is different than a critical part failing prematurely or whatever.

Unfortunately your argument makes sense.
That's probably the wording their lawyers asked them to use so they would not be liable for damages. If they admit fault, they're legally to blame for any accidents or damage.
Legally a defect in a product means you are stictly liable for all damage it causes.

But also the hackers haven't demo'd the exploit in an untampered with car. I still wonder if you need physical access to do this.

If my understanding is correct, Uconnect/Bluetooth security is the weakest link, which isn't much comfort.
Preemptively admitting fault probably creates issues if there is future litigation.