Hacker News new | ask | show | jobs
by Arnt 4001 days ago
BTW there's a reason for that. The IETF decided (it must be a couple of decades ago) to restrict itself to matters of the internet. Things like file formats are thus out of scope for RFCs. There have been exceptions, RFC5952 is a good example and I know at least two others, but by and large RFCs are about the internet now, not about file formats or other worthy subjects.
2 comments

RFC 6120 and 6121 are for XMPP (chat), and define XML is to be used, and even goes into the exact structure of the XML "packets".
Bad example. XML is the wire format in XMPP RFCs, not a file format.
RFC7159? It even recommends a file extension.
That's a perfect example: Publishable as an RFC because the format is used in many APIs on the general internet, but also says a little about a local matter, in this case the file names.

Is the rule a bit messy? Yes it is!